Tribunal Orders Stockbroker to Pay Investor N3m Damages

Image

By Dipo Olowookere

Meristem Securities Limited has been directed by the Investments and Securities Tribunal (IST) in Abuja to pay the sum of N3 million as damages to an investor, Mr Steven Guar.

The fine was the stockbroker’s misconduct, which forced the capital market investor to incur some losses and hardship.

In his ruling, Mr Jude Ike Udunni, who presided over the tribunal, held that evidence showed that Meristem Securities Limited failed to discharge the duty of care required of it to the investor who is its client.

He further ordered the company to take immediate steps to ensure that all shares, dividends, and bonuses accrued and still outstanding to the applicant be credited to his CSCS account.

Mr Guar had filed a suit against Meristem Securities Limited and the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC).

He claimed that the share certificates he deposited with the company for verification and dematerialisation in 2008 was lost by Meristem Securities Limited, but was only informed about the loss in 2014.

According to him, he read about the loss in 2014 from the company’s reply to a regulatory query from SEC, where they claimed his share certificates were lost in transit between their Kaduna and Lagos offices.

The applicant also complained that Meristem Securities Limited failed to account for the whereabouts of another 50,000 units of Access Bank Plc shares he bought through it in an Initial Public Offer (IPO) in 2004.

According to the particulars of the case, Mr Guar sometime in 2004 bought 50,000 units of Access Bank Plc shares through Meristem Securities Limited and gave his office address as Jos, Plateau State.

From that time, he did not hear anything again about the shares allocation/allotment nor was a share certificate delivered to him until 2012 when he accidentally received a dividend bonus certificate issued on the shares in 2008.

He, thereafter, made inquiries and got to know that his address on the shares subscription form was changed to another address in Ikoyi, Lagos.

The address in Lagos belonging to the company was where his dividends, bonuses and letters were channelled. He demanded from the company the original certificate of the shares as well as the other bonuses and dividends that had accrued which they failed to oblige.

Also, in 2008, the applicant in another separate transaction travelled to the Kaduna Office branch of the company and handed them various share certificates of different companies in which he held shares to take to the Central Securities Clearing System (CSCS) in Lagos to verify, dematerialise and credit into his account only for the company to fail to account for the whereabouts of those other share certificates.

Mr Guar, after failing to resolve the issues even with the intervention of SEC, approached the Tribunal seeking eight declarative remedies including an order that he was entitled to know the whereabouts of his share certificates; that the certificates be returned to him and that the withholding of dividends accrued from his 50,000 units of shares till date was illegal.

He also sought an order to compel SEC to direct Meristem Securities to regularise documentation of his shares with his Registrar and consolidate his accrued dividends, bonuses and interests, among others.

But in its defence, Meristem Securities Limited informed the Tribunal that the share certificates were lost in transit between their Kaduna and Lagos offices.

On the entry of a wrong address in his offer application form and incorrect routing of his letters to their Lagos office which kept him in the shadows, the company denied responsibility arguing that Registrars were responsible for custody of addresses and dispatch of mails.

Meristem also argued that though the certificates were lost, the client’s shares were still intact. However, the client proved before the Tribunal how the value of the shares eroded drastically during the market tumble that took place.

Share
Related Stories
Image
02-March-2024

Naira Now N1,548.25 at Official Market, N1,560/$1 at Black Market

By Adedapo Adesanya The Naira sustained its gradual recovery against the US Dollar in the Nigerian Autonomous Foreign Exchange Market (NAFEM) on Friday, March 1, appreciating by 2.94 per cent or N46.86 to sell at N1,548.25/$1, in contrast to the N1,595.11/$1 it was traded on Thursday. Also, in the spot market, the Nigerian currency improved its value against the Pound Sterling during the trading day by N90.13 to close at N1,956.06/£1 versus the previous day’s N2,046.19/£1 and against the Euro, it gained N76.39 to trade at N1,675.25/€1, in contrast to the N1,751.64/€1 it closed a day earlier. The supply of

Image
01-March-2024

Business Confidence in Nigeria Falls in February Amid Rise in Input Costs

By Modupe Gbadeyanka Business conditions in Nigeria slowed to 51.0 in February 2024 from 54.5 in January 2024, as price pressures intensified in the private sector at an unprecedented pace in over a decade of data collection, the Stanbic IBTC Bank Purchasing Managers’ Index (PMI) has revealed. A statement from the lender disclosed that the improvement in business conditions was the weakest since the recovery in the private sector began last December. It stated that input costs surged higher in the period under consideration as a result of higher fuel prices and exchange rate weakness, which drove up material costs.

Image
29-February-2024

Navigating the Complex World of Investing: What Novices Need to Know

Have you finally decided to take the leap into the exciting arena of investing? Not only is this an excellent way to secure a lucrative nest egg for the future, but many have begun to use these opportunities as a springboard for their businesses. However, appreciating the intricacies of online trading is no easy task. A great deal of preparation will be required and mistakes can occur on occasion. This is why knowing where to begin is one of the best ways to establish strong foundations. Let us therefore cut through a fair amount of “fluff” and examine a handful

More Stories
Image
06-December-2021

ICCO Hall of Fame Inducts First African, Yomi Badejo-Okusanya

By Aduragbemi Omiyale The prestigious International Communications Consultancy Organisation (ICCO) has inducted Mr Yomi Badejo-Okusanya (YBO) into its Hall of Fame. With this development, the President of the African Public Relations Association (APRA) and Group Managing Director of CMC Connect (Perception Managers), has become the first African to get the honour. Mr Badejo-Okusanya runs a PR firm based in Lagos and with the induction, he has joined the likes of UK Government Communication Executive Director, Alex Aiken; Global Women in PR co-founders, Angela Oakes and Susan Hardwick as Hall of Fame inductees. Accepting the honour during the ICCO Global Awards

Image
18-May-2018

Nigerian Firm Gets $100m Loan for Fertilizer Production

By Dipo Olowookere A credit facility worth $100 million has been given to Nigerian company known as Indorama Eleme Fertilizer and Chemicals Limited for the production of fertilizers in the country. The loan was granted by the African Development Bank (AfDB) and is expected to address the problem of inadequate fertilizer utilization, which is considered one of the principal constraints to agricultural growth and development in Nigeria, and the entire African continent. The firm is expected to use the loan to double its fertilizer production from 1.4 million tons of urea to 2.8 million tons per annum. Business Post reports

Image
02-March-2020

AfCFTA to Expand African Economy to $3.3trn—AfDB

By Adedapo Adesanya The African Development Bank (AfDB) has revealed that current projections indicate that with the African Continental Free Trade Area (AfCFTA), economies on the continent will reach $3.3 trillion. President of the bank, Mr Akinwumi Adesina, said at the African Leadership Persons of the Year Investiture Ceremonies and Awards Gala night held in Johannesburg, South Africa on Saturday, where he was honoured as the African of the Year that the size of business and consumer expenditures in Africa will rise to $5.6 trillion by 2025. Mr Adesina explained that with the current trend in size of food and

Image
14-April-2021

CSCS, VFD Group Sustain Growth at NASD OTC Exchange

By Adedapo Adesanya The NASD Over-the-Counter (OTC) Securities Exchange extended its bullish run to six days as it mounted a 0.75 per cent gain following positive price movement from VFD Group Plc and Central Securities Clearing Systems (CSCS) Plc on Tuesday, April 13. The run, which started after the Easter holidays last week, has seen the bull hold down the fort at the unlisted securities market, which has so far marked an impressive run this year. One of the companies responsible for this is the proprietary investment company, VFD Group Plc, which has refused to release its foothold on the

Image
30-January-2018

Registration for 2018 Cowbellpedia Maths Competition Closes Feb 11

**As Schools Mobilise Candidates By Modupe Gbadeyanka Public and private secondary schools across the country have been urged to register their best JSS 3 and SSS 2 candidates for the 2018 Cowbellpedia Senior Secondary Mathematics Television Quiz Show on or before the deadline of Sunday, February 11, which is just about three weeks away. At the press conference to flag off the 2018 edition, Promasidor Nigeria Limited, makers of Cowbell Milk, announced a 100 percent increase in the star prize from N1 million to N2 million, in addition to other incentives. It was the highlight of activities to commemorate 20

Image
29-November-2017

CBN Strengthens Forex Market with Fresh $210m

By Modupe Gbadeyanka The foreign exchange market in Nigeria was further strengthened yesterday by its apex bank with the release of fresh $210 million. According to the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN), the $210 million released on Tuesday was part of effort aimed at boosting liquidity in the forex market, facilitating trade and easing remittances for legitimate personal commitments. Spokesman of the chief lender, Mr Isaac Okorafor, stated that the Whole segment was supported with $100 million, while the Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs) sector had $55 million, and the invisibles window, (i.e. tuition fees, medical payments and Basic Travel

Image
30-May-2017

European Stocks Slump Amid Fresh Political Concerns

By Investors Hub European stocks extended declines for a fourth consecutive sessions on Tuesday as fresh political worries surrounding Britain, Italy and Greece sapped investors’ appetite for risk and helped spur demand for safe-haven assets. The pan-European Stoxx Europe 600 index was down 0.3 percent at 390.02 in late opening deals, extending losses for the fourth straight session. The German DAX was down about 0.1 percent while France’s CAC 40 index was losing as much as 0.8 percent. The UK’s FTSE 100 was down 0.3 percent as traders returned to their desks following a long holiday weekend. Banks led losses

Image
28-October-2020

Delta Raises 2021 Budget by 34%, to Spend N378.5bn

By Dipo Olowookere The budget estimate of Delta State for the 2021 fiscal year has been raised 34.05 per cent or N96.2 billion higher than the 2020 financial year by Governor Ifeanyi Okowa. On Tuesday, the Governor presented the Appropriation Bill to the Delta State House of Assembly and during the presentation, he said the sum of N378.48 billion is to be spent next year as against N282 billion approved for this year. Mr Okowa, who described the bill as Budget of Recovery, noted that more funds would be used to carry out projects across the state, justifying the reason

Ad
Ad
Recent Stories
Image
02-March-2024

JUST IN: Nollywood Star Mr Ibu Dies

By Modupe Gbadeyanka Information just reaching Business Post indicates that popular Nigerian actor, Mr John Okafor, otherwise known as Mr Ibu, is dead. It was gathered that the Nollywood star breathed his last on Saturday in a hospital in Lagos. His demise comes a day after the Nigeria film industry lost an actor, Mr Tolani Quadri Oyebamiji, well-known as Sisi Quadri. Mr Ibu underwent a surgery, which led to the amputation of one of his legs. He was later discharged from the hospital, but was reportedly taken back. Until his death, he acted in several movies. He was well known

Image
02-March-2024

African Bishops Seek Overhaul of Financial System as Debt Burden Worsens

African Catholic Bishops called for an overhaul of the financial system to address health, climate, food and other challenges the region faces. Ahead of a gathering of African Finance Ministers in Victoria Falls, Zimbabwe, the Justice, Peace and Development Commission of the Catholic Symposium of Episcopal Conferences of Africa and Madagascar (SECAM) outlined reforms for debt relief, development resources and governance. “In Sub-Saharan Africa the number of people facing food insecurity stress or crisis has more than doubled since 2019, reaching 420 million people last year,” noted the bishops in a statement. A delegation representing the African Bishops and religious

Image
02-March-2024

MTF Class of 2023 to Premiere Her Dark Past, Grown

By Modupe Gbadeyanka Two feature films will be premiered this weekend exclusively on the Africa Magic Showcase channel 151 and Africa Magic Urban channel 153 by the students of the MultiChoice Talent Factory (MTF). The two pieces of art titled Grown and Her Dark Past are the final projects of the MTF Class of 2023 students, a statement from the organisation said. The MTF is a leading film school in West Africa for young, talented and passionate filmmakers. It was established by the media platform to grow the region’s creative industry. Grown premieres on Africa Magic Showcase at 8.30 pm

Image
02-March-2024

Mandela’s Heirs Lose Power in South Africa

By Alexander Braterskiy South African authorities warn that if the opposition wins the parliamentary elections, the country may change course and leave the informal BRICS economic bloc, which includes Russia. The position of the African National Congress party, which has been in power since the collapse of apartheid, is indeed not the best, as shown by the municipal elections held earlier in the country. The opposition accuses the president of corruption and abuse of power, as well as an inability to cope with the country’s energy crisis. The ANC crisis occurred on the 30th anniversary of the first free elections

Image
02-March-2024

CAA Reaffirms Commitment to Climate Innovation for Sustainable Future

By Modupe Gbadeyanka A leading social enterprise focused on environmental sustainability, Climate Action Africa (CAA), has reaffirmed its commitment to being at the forefront of driving climate innovation for a sustainable future. The organization, which is a key participant at the four-day Omniverse Summit 2024 in Lagos, emphasised the need to integrate environmental sustainability models, technology, and community-driven innovation to address climate change challenges. It promised to foster an inclusive climate action ecosystem through innovation, which it said can be used to identify and scale solutions to address the imminent climate crisis in Nigeria and Africa as a whole, The

Image
02-March-2024

Endosurvivors Foundation Set For Another Endometriosis Awareness

By Adedapo Adesanya EndoSurvivors International Foundation (ESIF), an NGO championing endometriosis awareness in Nigeria, has announced its upcoming events in commemoration of the Global Endometriosis Advocacy Month in March, fondly tagged March4Endo by advocates all over the world.  Endometriosis is a chronic and inflammatory condition that affects approximately 1 in 10 girls and women in Nigeria and on a global scale. This sums up to about 190 million affected girls/women around the world, about the population of Nigeria in 2018.  The World Health Organisation (WHO) recognizes that endometriosis has significant social, public health, and economic implications leading to a decrease

Image
02-March-2024

CSCS, FrieslandCampina Lift NASD OTC Bourse by 0.31%

By Adedapo Adesanya The NASD Over-the-Counter (OTC) Securities Exchange returned to the positive territory after it gained 0.31 per cent on Friday, March 1, thanks to the duo of Central Securities Clearing System (CSCS) Plc and FrieslandCampina Wamco Nigeria Plc. CSCS Plc added 81 Kobo to its value to sell for N19.46 per unit compared with the preceding day’s N18.65 per unit, and FrieslandCampina improved by N1.15 to settle at N71.4o per share, in contrast to Thursday’s closing price of N70.25 per share. However, Aradel Holdings Plc continued its price depreciation yesterday as it shed N6.75 to sell at N2,395.00

Image
02-March-2024

Naira Now N1,548.25 at Official Market, N1,560/$1 at Black Market

By Adedapo Adesanya The Naira sustained its gradual recovery against the US Dollar in the Nigerian Autonomous Foreign Exchange Market (NAFEM) on Friday, March 1, appreciating by 2.94 per cent or N46.86 to sell at N1,548.25/$1, in contrast to the N1,595.11/$1 it was traded on Thursday. Also, in the spot market, the Nigerian currency improved its value against the Pound Sterling during the trading day by N90.13 to close at N1,956.06/£1 versus the previous day’s N2,046.19/£1 and against the Euro, it gained N76.39 to trade at N1,675.25/€1, in contrast to the N1,751.64/€1 it closed a day earlier. The supply of

Image
02-March-2024

Crude Oil Jumps 2% as Traders Sight Possible OPEC+ Cuts

By Adedapo Adesanya Crude oil appreciated by about 2 per cent on Friday as traders awaited a decision from the Organisation of the Petroleum Exporting Countries and allies (OPEC+) on supply agreements for the second quarter. Yesterday, the price of Brent futures went up by $1.64 or 2 per cent to $83.55 per barrel and the US West Texas Intermediate (WTI) futures rose by $1.71 or 2.19 per cent to $79.97 a barrel. For the week, Brent added around 2.4 per cent while WTI gained more than 4.5 per cent. Analysts noted that the expectation that OPEC+ is going to

Image
02-March-2024

NGX Indices Nosedive by 1.23% as Traders Resume Profit-Taking

By Dipo Olowookere The bears made a quick return to the Nigerian Exchange (NGX) Limited after leaving the stage for the bulls for a day as investors reassessed the impact of the hike in the benchmark interest rate by the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) on Tuesday on their investments. On Friday, the key performance indicators of the bourse closed lower by 1.23 per cent as a result of renewed selling pressure, especially in the energy and industrial goods sectors. Business Post reports that at the close of transactions on the first trading session of March 2024, the industrial goods