Africa: The Increasing Focus on Public Interest Concerns in Competition Policy

Image

By Lerisha Naidu, Angelo Tzarevski and Sphesihle Nxumalo

There has been a general upward trend in competition policy enforcement across the continent over the past few years. African jurisdictions have strengthened their competition and antitrust regimes by way of amendments to existing legislation, the introduction of new laws and regulations, and renewed fervour and political will to enforce existing laws. Most notably, there has been a growing convergence of competition law and social policy on the continent.

The central tenet of competition policy is that inclusive economies yield better outcomes for both producers and consumers. Recent trends indicate that governments in various parts of the world, particularly Africa, are moving away from the purely economic origins of competition regulation and are instead adopting a model that recognizes and, to some extent, caters to the broader needs of modern society and socioeconomic transformative narratives. In this context, the South African Competition Act was amended in 2019 to ensure economic transformation (among other things) by providing mechanisms to address high levels of concentration, enhance small business development, combat the “racially-skewed” spread of ownership through merger control, and by vesting the authority with increased powers to launch market inquiries into highly concentrated industries and impose structural remedies to facilitate the effective and sustainable participation of small and medium enterprises (SMEs) and historically disadvantaged persons (HDPs) in the economy.

As another illustration, competition authorities in Africa have increasingly acknowledged their role as protectors of fair practice and consumer protection and have stated their intention to enforce these principles in the future. Across the continent, the price volatility of essential food items is a growing concern. In addition, businesses in the consumer goods and retail sector are facing significant supply chain disruptions due to geopolitical, environmental, and infrastructure challenges.

The issue of price volatility in relation to essential food items was addressed in the South African competition authority’s Essential Food Pricing Monitoring report, which included a list of fruits, meats and cooking oils that have recently experienced price volatility. It was noted that poorer communities were most negatively affected by such price increases. Having said that, it bears noting that not all increases in the cost of essential foods were caused by the pandemic. Changing weather conditions (from drought to heavy rain), oil price fluctuations, severe supply chain blockages and massive geopolitical challenges have all contributed to a decrease in supply and subsequent price increases. The authority stated that it would continue to keep a close eye on the price of essential and imported food items to ensure that anti-competitive behaviour does not occur and that the increase in prices of essential food items can be justified. After noting “unjustified price increases” in recent years, the authority announced in early 2023 that it would investigate the prices of a variety of essential food products, including bread, cooking oils, cornmeal, rice, flour and margarine. It noted that food was a priority sector due to the fact that poor consumers spend a significant portion of their income on essential foodstuffs.

Public interest considerations are especially taken into account in the case of merger control, but they can also be factored in investigations into alleged abuses of dominance and other prohibited practices. Notably, merger regulation in South Africa and in many other African countries is heavily influenced by the government policy agenda. Many African merger control regimes have developed a competition policy approach that balances traditional competition law considerations with public interest concerns, especially in terms of market concentration, access to competitive markets for SMEs, greater spread of ownership by firms owned by HDPs, and employment considerations. For example:

    Botswana’s competition legislation mandates “certain aspects of general public interest”. The use of the specified public interest considerations is especially notable in the context of mergers. In previous years, the authority imposed conditions on merger clearances aimed at promoting the sustainability and growth of a sector by ensuring that the merged entity sources its input requirements from local suppliers; maintaining and creating employment; promoting citizen economic empowerment by ensuring that Botswanan citizens hold shares in the merged entity; ensuring the professional development or employability of local citizens by ordering their appointment to certain positions in the merged entity; and promoting citizen economic empowerment by ensuring that Botswanan citizens hold shares in the merged entity.

    In Ethiopia, the authority considers the contribution that a merger will make to accelerating economic development, promoting technical knowledge transfer, improving the production and distribution of goods and services, and enabling SMEs to be capable and competitive.

    Namibia and Nigeria, like South Africa, consider the likely impact of a merger on a specific industrial sector or region; employment (whether the merger will result in redundancies); SMEs’ and HDPs’ ability to effectively access or compete in the market; and national industries’ ability to compete in international markets. The Namibian authority frequently considers the employment implications of a transaction. For example, during the 2017-2018 fiscal year, the authority imposed employment conditions on the majority of the mergers evaluated, resulting in approximately 860 jobs being secured.

    In Kenya, the Competition Act includes a public interest test in merger control that assesses a merger’s impact on a particular sector or region, the creation and retention of employment and the competitive access that SMEs have to the market. The Act also provides for the granting of exemptions to certain indispensable restrictive practices aimed at increasing exports, enhancing efficiency in production and maintaining the quality of services only under exceptional and compelling reasons of public policy.

    In Tanzania, the public interest factor is especially important when a merger is likely to create or strengthen market dominance. In such cases, the authority may consider whether the merger is likely to benefit the public by increasing efficiency in production or distribution, promoting technological or economic progress, increasing efficiency in resource allocation, or protecting the environment.

Although legislatively mandated public interest factors frequently carry equal weight, the employment effects and promotion of ownership by local citizens (particularly in Botswana) and HDPs (particularly in South Africa) are scrutinized by the authorities in every transaction. Conditions are almost always imposed when job losses are intended or anticipated, even when the numbers are negligible. Even if job losses are not anticipated, conditions may nevertheless be imposed to safeguard against potential merger-specific job losses in cases of uncertainty. The promotion of greater ownership diversity, particularly among HDPs, is also gaining importance, especially as transactions that reduce ownership by historically disadvantaged individuals are scrutinized more closely by authorities. In the last 24 months, the South African competition authority has been particularly active, imposing public interest conditions on more than 74 mergers relating to employment, and with a heavy focus on the greater spread of ownership by HDPs, as well as local production and procurement, amongst others.

As social imperatives play an ever-increasing role in the development of competition policy, the trend of placing emphasis on the empowerment of SMEs as a means of fostering a healthy economic ecosystem, as well as the need to provide adequate opportunities to HDPs, will continue into the future. Furthermore, with digital innovation allowing many previously excluded individuals and businesses to participate in the African economy, it is likely that public interest imperatives will play a critical role in the development and implementation of competition law in the digital space across the continent.

The African Continental Free Trade Area (AfCFTA) is providing impetus for the continent to move toward the adoption of a pan-African competition policy, which could be geared toward socioeconomic transformative goals (such as maintaining acceptable consumer prices) and a consistent approach to the public interest. In February 2023, the African Union Assembly of Heads of State and Government adopted the protocol on competition policy.

Doing business in Africa will necessitate awareness of the public interest mandates of competition authorities and how practices promote or impact public interest outcomes, as enforcement trends on the continent indicate that public interest considerations will significantly influence broader enforcement activity, especially through prioritisation policies.

Lerisha Naidu is a Partner and Head of the Practice, Angelo Tzarevski is a Director Designate, and Sphesihle Nxumalo is a Senior Associate for Competition & Antitrust Practice at Baker McKenzie Johannesburg

Share
Related Stories
Image
20-February-2024

Navigating the Complexities of Media Monitoring: Strategies for Effective Brand Media Intelligence Gathering

By Philip Odiakose In today’s media landscape, the ability to monitor and analyze media coverage is crucial for brands seeking to stay ahead of the competition and maintain their reputation. However, the sheer volume and diversity of media sources, coupled with the ever-evolving nature of communication channels, present significant challenges for effective media monitoring. As the Chief Media Analyst at P+ Measurement Services, a leading Media Monitoring and Intelligence consultancy, I have firsthand experience in navigating these complexities. In this article, I will share key strategies for successfully gathering brand media intelligence amidst the intricacies of modern media environments. 1. Define

Image
16-February-2024

BRICS and the Global South Cooperation

By Professors Abdullahi Y. Shehu and Maurice Okoli Introduction Since the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1992 ‘the tectonic plates of geopolitics have been shifting’ and with current geopolitical tensions, including the Russian-Ukrainian conflict, the Israeli-Hamas war, new alliances and potential rivalry among world powers seeking for influence in Africa and other regions of the world, ‘we may see the world becoming more multipolar’. Despite the plethora of multilateral institutions, multipolarity has become a cliché as member states forge new alliances to address perceived injustices in the existing system. BRICS emerged from the Russia-India-China strategic triangle called RIC. The group

Image
13-February-2024

Aleph Presents Unique Strategies to Grow Business This Ramadan

As Muslims around the world get ready to celebrate the holy month of Ramadan, Aleph (formerly known as Ad Dynamo by Aleph) presents insights for businesses on how best to leverage Meta platforms for business growth. Did you know that… Ramadan’s focus on community and connection also enables brands to connect in a unique way with the audience? The research also shows that 91% of social media users in Nigeria like to see content that promotes community and togetherness on Facebook and Instagram. Advertising that respects and highlights Ramadan’s traditions, businesses can enter the conversation in a new and positive

Image
05-February-2024

A Cultural Journalist’s 15 years of Research on Ijaw Culture and Worship

By Jerome-Mario Utomi No man, according to Aristotle, chooses anything but what he can do himself. And thus, choice is limited to the realm of things humanly possible. Aristotle further stated that there is no choice among impossibilities. Choice, by its very nature, is free. A necessitated choice is not a choice at all but a great sacrifice, he concluded. The above lines from great Aristotle amply capture the ‘fate’ or better still the position of Asiayei Enaibo, Bobogbene community, a Warri, Delta state-based journalist who made a necessitated choice/sacrifice by opting out of conventional journalism to explore formation that

More Stories
Image
03-December-2020

NASD Exchange Bleeds as Investors Lose N7.64bn

By Adedapo Adesanya The NASD Over-the-Counter (OTC) Securities Exchange on Wednesday, December 2 further bled after it depreciated by 1.41 per cent. It was the third consecutive loss it was recording as investors are struggling to have confidence in the market, especially because of the economic crisis in the country. During the midweek session, the market capitalisation of the bourse slumped by N7.64 billion to close at N534.86 billion compared to N542.50 billion it ended on Tuesday. Equally, the NASD Unlisted Security Index (NSI) also depreciated by 10.28 points to close at 719.57 points as against 729.85 points it finished

Image
23-April-2021

WACOT, Syngenta Work to Help Nigeria Attain Self-Sufficiency in Food

By Modupe Gbadeyanka Efforts are currently being made to ensure Nigeria attains self-sufficiency in food so as to significantly cut down the amount food imported into the country. Two companies are working together to boost Nigeria’s food security and ensure sustainable development of the agriculture sector, which is the nation’s highest employer of labour, accounting for 70 per cent, but has suffered low output resulting in poor returns for farmers and massive food import. It gathered that a leading food and agro-processing company in West Africa, WACOT Limited, and leading global agritech company, Syngenta Crop Protection, would be working closely

Image
08-April-2017

EFCC Uncovers N.5b Hidden in Lagos Shopping Plaza

By Dipo Olowookere Almost N500 million has been discovered from a shopping plaza in Lagos by the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC). It was gathered that the money was stashed in several Ghana Must Go bags and in N500 and N1000 denominations, hidden in a shop awaiting conversion into foreign currency. The discovery, we learnt, was made on Friday evening by the anti-graft agency in a shop at LEGICO Shopping Plaza on Ahmadu Bello Way, Victoria Island, Lagos. The total amount recovered was N448.9 million. It was said that the EFCC raided the premises following a tip-off by a

Image
09-December-2022

ASEA Elects Popoola as Executive Committee Member

By Aduragbemi Omiyale The chief executive of the Nigerian Exchange (NGX) Limited, Mr Temi Popoola, has been elected as an executive committee member of the African Securities Exchanges Association (ASEA). His election into the team was at the association’s Annual General Meeting and Conference held in Abidjan, Cote D’ Ivoire, on December 7, 2022. Also elected at the event was the CEO of the Botswana Stock Exchange, Thapelo Tsheole as the president and the CEO of the Rwanda Stock Exchange, Pierre Celestine Rwabukumba, as the Vice President of ASEA. ASEA is the continent’s prime association of securities exchanges, established in

Image
15-March-2020

Emeka Oparah Emerges Communications Practitioner of the Decade

Airtel Nigeria’s Director of Corporate Communications & Corporate Social Responsibility, Mr Emeka Oparah, has been honoured with the Communications Practitioner of the Decade Award. Mr Oparah, who was honoured during the Communications Industry Evening, was described as a master of crisis management and one of the longest serving communication practitioners in a single organisation in spite of several brand and ownership changes. The event, which held at the Sheraton Hotel, Ikeja, Lagos on Friday, March 6, 2020, was attended by advertising and communications practitioners drawn from different agencies as well as corporate and multinational organisations. According to a citation read

Image
08-November-2019

Futures Pointing to Roughly Flat Open on Wall Street

By Investors Hub The major U.S. index futures are currently pointing to a roughly flat opening on Friday, as traders seem likely to retreat to the sidelines once again. Stocks may resume the lackluster performance seen earlier in the week amid renewed uncertainty about a potential U.S.-China trade deal. News U.S. and Chinese negotiators had agreed to roll back existing tariffs as part of a phase one trade deal contributed to early strength on Thursday. However, buying interest waned after a report from Reuters said the idea faces fierce internal opposition from President Donald Trump?s advisers. Multiple sources familiar with

Image
06-April-2017

Voyageur Minerals Stakes Lithium King in Utah

By InvestorsHub Voyageur Minerals Ltd has announced staking additional lithium rich brine claims in Utah USA named the Lithium King Project. Voyageur has recently staked 75 new placer claims 607 ha. (1500 acres) and in addition, has acquired an additional 21 existing placer claims 170 ha (420 acres) of lithium claims in the Bonneville Salt Flats area in Utah, USA. This brings the total acreage in Utah under Voyageur’s control to 777 ha (1920 acres) (95 claims). Based on published lithium values in numerous surrounding brine monitoring wells, the average lithium grades are 215 ppm with the highest grades recorded

Image
19-November-2018

Doctors Highlight Causes of Complicated Pregnancies, Deliveries

By Modupe Gbadeyanka Over the past 10 years, Médecins Sans Frontières (MSF), known in English as Doctors Without Borders, has assisted more than 54,000 deliveries, most of them complicated, in Jahun General Hospital, Jigawa state. To reduce maternal and neonatal mortality, the international medical organisation provides emergency obstetrics and neonatal care in collaboration with the Jigawa State Ministry of Health. To commemorate the 10-year anniversary of this collaboration, a Forum on Maternal Health was held on November 13 and 14, 2018 in Dutse and Jahun. Doctors and experts from the field of maternal health and officials from the Ministry of

Ad
Ad
Recent Stories
Image
02-March-2024

MTF Class of 2023 to Premiere Her Dark Past, Grown

By Modupe Gbadeyanka Two feature films will be premiered this weekend exclusively on the Africa Magic Showcase channel 151 and Africa Magic Urban channel 153 by the students of the MultiChoice Talent Factory (MTF). The two pieces of art titled Grown and Her Dark Past are the final projects of the MTF Class of 2023 students, a statement from the organisation said. The MTF is a leading film school in West Africa for young, talented and passionate filmmakers. It was established by the media platform to grow the region’s creative industry. Grown premieres on Africa Magic Showcase at 8.30 pm

Image
02-March-2024

Mandela’s Heirs Lose Power in South Africa

By Alexander Braterskiy South African authorities warn that if the opposition wins the parliamentary elections, the country may change course and leave the informal BRICS economic bloc, which includes Russia. The position of the African National Congress party, which has been in power since the collapse of apartheid, is indeed not the best, as shown by the municipal elections held earlier in the country. The opposition accuses the president of corruption and abuse of power, as well as an inability to cope with the country’s energy crisis. The ANC crisis occurred on the 30th anniversary of the first free elections

Image
02-March-2024

CAA Reaffirms Commitment to Climate Innovation for Sustainable Future

By Modupe Gbadeyanka A leading social enterprise focused on environmental sustainability, Climate Action Africa (CAA), has reaffirmed its commitment to being at the forefront of driving climate innovation for a sustainable future. The organization, which is a key participant at the four-day Omniverse Summit 2024 in Lagos, emphasised the need to integrate environmental sustainability models, technology, and community-driven innovation to address climate change challenges. It promised to foster an inclusive climate action ecosystem through innovation, which it said can be used to identify and scale solutions to address the imminent climate crisis in Nigeria and Africa as a whole, The

Image
02-March-2024

Endosurvivors Foundation Set For Another Endometriosis Awareness

By Adedapo Adesanya EndoSurvivors International Foundation (ESIF), an NGO championing endometriosis awareness in Nigeria, has announced its upcoming events in commemoration of the Global Endometriosis Advocacy Month in March, fondly tagged March4Endo by advocates all over the world.  Endometriosis is a chronic and inflammatory condition that affects approximately 1 in 10 girls and women in Nigeria and on a global scale. This sums up to about 190 million affected girls/women around the world, about the population of Nigeria in 2018.  The World Health Organisation (WHO) recognizes that endometriosis has significant social, public health, and economic implications leading to a decrease

Image
02-March-2024

CSCS, FrieslandCampina Lift NASD OTC Bourse by 0.31%

By Adedapo Adesanya The NASD Over-the-Counter (OTC) Securities Exchange returned to the positive territory after it gained 0.31 per cent on Friday, March 1, thanks to the duo of Central Securities Clearing System (CSCS) Plc and FrieslandCampina Wamco Nigeria Plc. CSCS Plc added 81 Kobo to its value to sell for N19.46 per unit compared with the preceding day’s N18.65 per unit, and FrieslandCampina improved by N1.15 to settle at N71.4o per share, in contrast to Thursday’s closing price of N70.25 per share. However, Aradel Holdings Plc continued its price depreciation yesterday as it shed N6.75 to sell at N2,395.00

Image
02-March-2024

Naira Now N1,548.25 at Official Market, N1,560/$1 at Black Market

By Adedapo Adesanya The Naira sustained its gradual recovery against the US Dollar in the Nigerian Autonomous Foreign Exchange Market (NAFEM) on Friday, March 1, appreciating by 2.94 per cent or N46.86 to sell at N1,548.25/$1, in contrast to the N1,595.11/$1 it was traded on Thursday. Also, in the spot market, the Nigerian currency improved its value against the Pound Sterling during the trading day by N90.13 to close at N1,956.06/£1 versus the previous day’s N2,046.19/£1 and against the Euro, it gained N76.39 to trade at N1,675.25/€1, in contrast to the N1,751.64/€1 it closed a day earlier. The supply of

Image
02-March-2024

Crude Oil Jumps 2% as Traders Sight Possible OPEC+ Cuts

By Adedapo Adesanya Crude oil appreciated by about 2 per cent on Friday as traders awaited a decision from the Organisation of the Petroleum Exporting Countries and allies (OPEC+) on supply agreements for the second quarter. Yesterday, the price of Brent futures went up by $1.64 or 2 per cent to $83.55 per barrel and the US West Texas Intermediate (WTI) futures rose by $1.71 or 2.19 per cent to $79.97 a barrel. For the week, Brent added around 2.4 per cent while WTI gained more than 4.5 per cent. Analysts noted that the expectation that OPEC+ is going to

Image
02-March-2024

NGX Indices Nosedive by 1.23% as Traders Resume Profit-Taking

By Dipo Olowookere The bears made a quick return to the Nigerian Exchange (NGX) Limited after leaving the stage for the bulls for a day as investors reassessed the impact of the hike in the benchmark interest rate by the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) on Tuesday on their investments. On Friday, the key performance indicators of the bourse closed lower by 1.23 per cent as a result of renewed selling pressure, especially in the energy and industrial goods sectors. Business Post reports that at the close of transactions on the first trading session of March 2024, the industrial goods

Image
01-March-2024

CBN Revokes Operational Licences of 4,173 BDC Operators [FULL LIST]

By Aduragbemi Omiyale The operational licences of 4,173 Bureaux De Change (BDC) operators have been revoked by the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN). A statement signed by the acting Director of the Corporate Communications Department of the apex bank, Mrs Hakama Sidi Ali, on Friday disclosed that the action was taken because the affected BDCs did not adhere to regulatory provisions. The central bank said the BDCs did not pay all necessary fees, including licence renewal, within the stipulated period in line with guidelines. It also said they failed to give account of returns in line with the guidelines, and

Image
01-March-2024

BREAKING: Popular Yoruba Comic Actor Sisi Quadri Dies

By Modupe Gbadeyanka A popular Yoruba comic actor, Mr Tolani Quadri Oyebamiji, otherwise known as Sisi Quadri, has died, according to reports. However, the cause of his death is still unclear as of the time of filing this report. There are speculations that he briefly fell ill before his passing, though he was seen publicly some months ago with a fellow comic actor, Sanusi Izihaq, who is well-known as Apa or Apankufor. Sisi Quadri, who died at the age of 44, was recently gaining fresh public attention with his comic act with Apa and others. His demise has hit the