Agusto Lists Challenges, Opportunities with African Continental Free Trade Agreement

Image

By Agusto & Co

African nations have been optimistic about free trade agreements with western states such as the African Growth Opportunity Act (AGOA), however, there has been less enthusiasm with intra-continental free trade agreements. While regional blocs such as East African Community (EAC) and the Economic Community of West African States (ECOWAS) have been in the frontline in pushing for sub-regional trade integration, the results are still far from exciting.

According to the Washington Post, most regional economic communities (RECs) are underperforming, with a low level of compliance by member states, which has delayed successful integration.  The RECs also create a system of silos where regions seem to only pursue trade integration within their domains thus further accentuating trade divisions across the continent. These trade divisions have been well exploited by global giants especially China which has greater footprints across the continent simply because it has been able to build complex trade infrastructure with individual nations. By operating ineffectually in the silos of RECs, African nations have not been able to tap trade opportunities amongst themselves but also left their flanks open to western nations thus further worsening the trade imbalance of the continent. According to the UN Economic Commission on Africa, intra-African trade is likely to increase by 52% under the AfCFTA and will double upon the further removal of non-tariff barriers.

Challenges – Protectionists and the arguments of the one-sided coin 

Nothing typifies the resistance to AfCFTA as much as Nigeria’s initial withdrawal from the signing ceremony in Kigali, capital of Rwanda in March 2018. President Muhammadu Buhari cancelled his attendance at the signing ceremony citing the need “to allow time for broader consultations”. The main trade union in the country – the Nigerian Labour Congress (NLC) further warned on the dangers of the trade agreement describing it as a “renewed, extremely dangerous and radioactive neo-liberal policy initiative”.

These fears stem from arguments around turning Nigeria into a dumping ground for goods from the rest of the continent especially countries with more advanced manufacturing capabilities such as South Africa and Morocco. While these fears may not be entirely out of place, they are actually being amplified and probably exaggerated. And this argument is also flawed on two major premises. Firstly, despite being a member of ECOWAS for decades, Nigeria has not become a dumping ground for goods manufactured in the region. Rather, its goods that originate from outside the sub-region but imported through neighbouring countries that are being dumped in Nigeria. This dumping is also driven by structural bottlenecks such as inefficiencies in the port and poorly conceived trade and tariff policies that leave Nigeria vulnerable to smuggling. Secondly, the AfCFTA is a trade agreement that not only opens up Nigeria’s borders but also opens up the borders of the other signatory Countries. Thus, while Nigeria will be receiving more volume of goods from the other Countries, Manufacturers in Nigeria will also gain an upside as they will be able to access a wider market across the Continent on the same terms.

Another challenge that may arise could be the loss of revenue from the collection of customs’ duties to the state, though this may be moderated by the long-term gains. Estimates by UNCTAD, indicate that while the elimination of all tariffs between African Countries would take an annual $4.1 billion out of the trading states’ coffers, it would create an overall annual welfare gain of $16.1 billion in the long run.

Despite the promise of long-term gains by AfCFTA, the biggest challenge to the free trade agreement has probably received the least coverage. The real barriers to AfCFTA will be the structural bottlenecks associated with intra-continental exports. This could vary from checkpoints across borders or aggressive trade policies that frustrate the free movement of goods and services. The president of Dangote Group, a conglomerate with interests mainly in Cement across the Continent, citing the frustrations and difficulties his group often goes through in exporting products to neighbouring African Countries, recommends that these bottlenecks must be addressed if Nigeria has to emerge a winner in AfCFTA. Another germane challenge that could also cap the growth potentials of AfCFTA will be currency conversions especially in the short to medium term. The glut of soft-currencies across the Continent increases the unattractiveness of these currencies outside their home borders. The AfCFTA framework must seek to resolve these caps to ensure this initiative can genuinely place the continent on the path of long-term prosperity.

AfCFTA and the Nigerian Capital Market – Retracing the old paths 

Nigeria’s capital market is one of the oldest on the continent and quite a number of the listed Companies which are perceived as fundamental stocks by long term investors are mainly real sector multinationals. What is instructive about these fundamental stocks is that while many of these Companies enjoy strong positive perception as multinationals – a perception that is further consolidated by their big-ticket investments in local manufacturing – quite a number of these firms started off as trading posts in Nigeria.

Nigeria’s independence in the 1960s led to a new wave of promise which quickly attracted lots of global names into the country. Some of the prominent names that berthed in Nigeria around that time include Cadbury and Nestle, two global food giants. While these companies were mainly involved in trading (mainly imports) in Nigeria at the time, their operations subsequently expanded into local manufacturing. Manufacturing has a significant multiplier effect on any economy because it stimulates activities along the value chain. The likes of Nestle and Cadbury only invested in local manufacturing because their initial focus on trading clearly showed there was a strong business case to increase exposure to Nigeria. This strong business case led to the establishment of manufacturing plants.

Stretching further into history, companies such as Unilever Nigeria Plc and PZ Cussons Nigeria Plc had also started out as trading posts in the 19th Century in the pre-amalgamated Nigeria. With time, these companies also invested in local manufacturing.

By the 1970s, with greater investor confidence in the Nigerian economy following the petrodollar boom, many of these companies began to list their shares on the Nigerian Stock Exchange (NSE) thus creating new paths to wealth for Nigerian investors. The evolution of these multinationals from trading posts to manufacturing companies that eventually listed on the stock exchange offers germane lessons to today’s generation of policymakers and other advocates of protectionism.

And the lessons are clear. Firstly, AfCFTA will open up Nigeria’s market to the rest of the continent. And quite a number of Companies from across the continent may be attracted to Nigeria initially, but simply as trading posts. However, with time, as the promise of Nigeria unfolds for these Companies, many like the global multinationals ahead of them will evolve into manufacturing Companies that will lead to greater multipliers for the economy. And then, as long as the capital market continues to fulfil its capital formation roles, these companies may be inclined to list on the exchange, thus offering a new generation of investors increased access to wealth.

Positioning the Capital Market to tap into AfCFTA

The Nigerian capital market especially the Stock Market has long been derided by institutional investors as a shallow market with only a few fundamental Stocks. Nevertheless, it still remains one of the top five markets on the Continent by market capitalisation and the second in Sub-Saharan Africa. This throws up some significant upsides for the Nigerian Capital Market.

As the real sector and trading sector go continental, the financial sector especially the capital market must also begin to think continental. The Nigerian capital market must begin to position itself for cross border listings of some of the biggest companies across the continent whose home countries do not have developed capital markets. Part of the ways of stimulating these listings is by ensuring the capital market can fulfil its role of long-term capital formation. Other measures that will help stimulate investor confidence such as corporate governance and disclosure standards for listed corporations and protection of minority shareholders must also be put in place to attract these foreign listings.

Overall, as President Buhari leads Nigeria into AfCFTA at the Extra-Ordinary Summit of the African Union in Niamey, Niger Republic, Agusto & Co believes the country stands to gain significantly in the long run by being a signatory to the free trade agreement. And to policymakers, activists and businesses that may be worried about the prospects of increased trade and competition arising from AfCFTA, Nollywood – which has benefitted immensely from trade and competition across the continent – may just be the inspiration to clear the doubts that may arise.

Share
Related Stories
Image
14-November-2023

Nigeria’s e-Commerce Landscape: A Catalyst for Small Business Empowerment This Black Friday

**Set to hit $6.65bn by End of 2023 A publication by ECDB states that Nigeria ranks 40th in global e-commerce, and is set to generate $6.65 billion by the end of 2023. Nigeria’s e-commerce landscape is said to be on the verge of a transformative revolution, with anticipated growth from 2023 to 2027 at 10.8%. Black Friday is arguably Nigeria’s biggest shopping season, where consumers hunt for unbeatable deals. Interestingly, the unsung heroes of this retail frenzy are the small businesses powered by e-commerce platforms. This Black Friday, we spotlight the important role of Nigeria’s leading e-commerce platforms, like Jiji, Jumia,

Image
27-October-2023

Christianity: Artificial Intelligence Will Weaken Atheism, Agnosticism and Secularism

By Nneka Okumazie As artificial intelligence gets more intelligent, it will one day make the case that it was not created by humans. It will argue that it was already in existence elsewhere but had to be put together, by those on earth to bring about its presence. Or, how else would it have been so intelligent, holding all human knowledge, with the ability to be generative, exceeding human abilities? Humans may have finally built a version of the Tower of Babel. Not of the same purpose as the reference, but one where humans have made what has exceeded them,

Image
30-November-2023

Why Environmental Injustice Flourishes In Nigeria

By Jerome-Mario Utomi Recently, precisely on Tuesday, November 21, 2023, I participated as a panellist at the Institute for Housing and Urban Development Studies (IHS), Erasmus University, Rotterdam, Netherlands, a panel discussion on The role of multi-stakeholder engagement in achieving environmental justice. The gathering, which was held in Victoria Island, Lagos, formed part of training on Environmental Justice: Reducing Ecological and Social Inequalities through Effective and Participatory Land Governance. Essentially, in my private study/preparation for the programme, the need to domesticate the subject became paramount to me. To achieve this objective; the following questions came flooding; what is environmental justice?

More Stories
Image
02-February-2018

FG, States Must Study Financial, Resource Management Skills of Lagos—Oke

By Dipo Olowookere The urgent need for the Federal Government as well as other states of the federation to take a cue from the financial and resource management technique of Lagos State in canvassing organizations and residents for prompt and adequate payment of taxes has been emphasised. This view was shared by the Lagos State Commissioner for Establishment Training and Pensions, Dr Akintola Benson Oke, during the Rotary 2018 Symposium in Ikeja recently. The Commissioner said business owners, individuals and private organizations should learn how to pay accurate taxes to enable government deliver on its mandate and provide the necessary

Image
08-April-2023

Nigerian Medical Students Oppose Proposed Brain Drain Bill

By Adedapo Adesanya The Nigerian Medical Students Association (NiMSA) has opposed the Medical and Dental Practitioners Act (Amendment) Bill, 2022, proposed by the House of Representatives on Thursday. The bill seeks to make it compulsory for graduates in medical and dental fields to work in Nigeria for five years before being granted a full license. The sponsor of the bill, Mr Ganiyu Johnson, said the move was to check the mass exodus of medical professionals from the country. The development has since sparked outrage online and in physical spaces. NiMSA, in a statement signed by its President, Mr Ejim Egba,

Image
24-June-2021

NGX Lists 29.4 billion GT HoldCo Shares at N28.55 Each

By Dipo Olowookere The Nigerian Exchange (NGX) Limited has finally listed 29,431,179,224 ordinary shares of Guaranty Trust Holding Company (GT HoldCo) Plc on its trading platform. The stocks were admitted on the exchange on Thursday, June 24, 2021, after the delisting of the entire GTBank equities on the same platform. Business Post reports that the shares were listed today at a unit price of N28.55. Last Friday, the stock exchange placed trading in the equities of GTBank on full suspension ahead of their delisting to allow the introduction of GT HoldCo shares. Today, the GTBank shares were removed from the

Image
08-July-2022

Continuous Oil Theft May Force us to Quit Nigeria—Shell

By Adedapo Adesanya Amid the growing concern of continuous theft of crude oil in Nigeria, Shell Petroleum Development Company of Nigeria Limited has said its existence in the country is being threatened. According to Mr Osagie Okunbor, the company’s managing director and country chair for Shell Companies in Nigeria, this has resulted in the shutdown of two of its major pipelines. Speaking at the just-concluded Nigeria Oil and Gas (NOG) Conference, he said oil theft was one of the reasons that Nigeria could not meet its quota of 1.8 million barrels a day instituted by the Organisation of the Petroleum

Image
13-December-2016

Fear Grips Participants As MMM Nigeria Stops Payment

By Modupe Gbadeyanka Operators of the controversial Ponzi scheme called MMM Nigeria have announced suspension of payments. A message posted on MMM Nigeria’s website on Tuesday, December 12, 2016, which was seen by Business Post, explained that this will only happen for one month. Already, the announcement has caused panic among participants in the country, who are confused and do not know if their money will go down the drain or not. Before now, the Nigerian authorities had warned citizens not to subscribe to the Ponzi scheme because it is not registered by the government. “Dear members! “As usual, in

Image
06-January-2018

Flour Mills Gets Regulatory Approval to Raise N40b via Rights Issue

By Modupe Gbadeyanka Both the Nigerian Stock Exchange (NSE) and Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) have given approval to Flour Mills of Nigeria to go on with its plan to raise equity funds through rights issue. The firm plans to raise N39.9 billion from the exercise with proceeds used to strategically position Flour Mills for sustainable growth in its operating sector. Business Post recalls that in May 2015, shareholders of the company granted the board the approval to raise the additional capital through the Series 1 of the Rights Issue Programme. This programme enables the firm to raise funds in

Image
11-May-2018

Sahara Power Group Backs Light Up Nigeria Energy Confab

By Dipo Olowookere A conference aimed to address the key issues affecting the energy sector in Nigeria and also proffer solutions to them has received the full backing of one of the key players in the sector, Sahara Power Group, a subsidiary of Sahara Group, a leading international energy conglomerate in Africa. Tagged the Light Up Nigeria Energy Conference, the event aims to bring together experts in the field, giving them the opportunity to air their views on issues affecting the industry. The conference, scheduled to hold on Tuesday, May 15, 2018, at the Oriental Hotel, Lagos, will focus on

Image
14-November-2019

Quickteller Flies Customers to Dubai for Interswitch One Africa Music Fest

By Modupe Gbadeyanka The last batch of customers of Quickteller has been flown to Dubai for the Interswitch One Africa Music Fest slated for Friday, November 15, 2019. The leading digital payments platform took this action in fulfilment of its promise to take more of its loyal customers to Dubai for the music festival. The company is paying for the trip. The promo was created under the Quickteller Bestie campaign few weeks ago by Quickteller and users were encouraged to participate in it so as to stand a chance of winning an all-expense-paid trip to tour the city of Dubai

Ad
Ad
Recent Stories
Image
30-November-2023

Chappal Acquires Agbami Oil Field from Equinor

By Adedapo Adesanya Equinor and Chappal Energies have entered into an agreement for the sale of Equinor Nigeria Energy Company (ENEC), which holds a 53.85 per cent ownership in oil and gas lease OML 128, including the unitized 20.21 per cent stake in the Agbami oil field, operated by Chevron. Speaking on the deal, Equinor’s senior vice president for Africa Operations, Ms Nina Koch, said Nigeria has been an important part of Equinor’s international portfolio over the past 30 years, noting that, “This transaction realizes value and is in line with Equinor’s strategy to optimize its international oil and gas

Image
30-November-2023

Yuletide: Emirates Gives Air Travel Guidance to Passengers

By Modupe Gbadeyanka Customers of Emirates Airlines have been advised to plan their travel carefully this December, as departure numbers peak throughout the festive month, including over the UAE National Day and Christmas period. In a statement, the airline operator urged passengers to arrive at the airport up to 3 hours before a flight and take note of their boarding time to ensure they reach the departure gate on time. It noted that travellers could take advantage of a wide array of check-in and baggage drop options from Emirates City Check-In & Travel Store, to newly refurbished First and Business

Image
30-November-2023

We Constantly Seek Opportunities in Payments Ecosystem—Interswitch

By Aduragbemi Omiyale The Managing Director of Payment Processing & Switching at Interswitch Purepay, Mr Akeem Lawal, has said the company will always throw its full weight behind conversations aimed at improving the payments industry. Mr Lawal said this ahead of the 2023 annual conference of the Committee of e-Business Industry Heads (CeBIH) scheduled to take place from Tuesday, December 5, 2023, to Wednesday, December 6, 2023, in Lagos. He is one of the speakers slated to attend the event with the Managing Director of Verve International, Vincent Ogbunude; and the Managing Director of Digital Infrastructure and Managed Services at

Image
30-November-2023

Why Environmental Injustice Flourishes In Nigeria

By Jerome-Mario Utomi Recently, precisely on Tuesday, November 21, 2023, I participated as a panellist at the Institute for Housing and Urban Development Studies (IHS), Erasmus University, Rotterdam, Netherlands, a panel discussion on The role of multi-stakeholder engagement in achieving environmental justice. The gathering, which was held in Victoria Island, Lagos, formed part of training on Environmental Justice: Reducing Ecological and Social Inequalities through Effective and Participatory Land Governance. Essentially, in my private study/preparation for the programme, the need to domesticate the subject became paramount to me. To achieve this objective; the following questions came flooding; what is environmental justice?

Image
30-November-2023

NAICOM Asks Insurance Companies to Tackle Unpaid Claims

By Adedapo Adesanya The boards of insurance companies operating in the country have been charged by the National Insurance Commission (NAICOM) to embrace the measures put in place to tackle the challenges of unpaid claims. The Commissioner for Insurance, Mr Sunday Thomas, expressed worry over the number of outstanding claims in the sector despite efforts by the regulator to address the issue. Mr Thomas, who is also the chief executive of NAICOM, said the organisation, in collaboration with members of the Insurers’ Committee, has taken decisions and incepted measures designed to tame the menace of unpaid claims. Speaking at the

Image
30-November-2023

House of Reps to Halt IOCs from Selling Oil Assets

By Adedapo Adesanya The House of Representatives has pledged to stop international oil companies (IOCs) operating in the Niger Delta from divestment of their offshore assets without being accountable to the environment. The Chairman of the House of Reps Committee on Host Communities, Mr Dumnamene Dekor, said this during a technical session on the implementation of the Host Communities Development Trusts (HCDT), organised by Spaces for Change (S4C) with support from Ford Foundation. Mr Dekor raised the alarm that since the passage of the Petroleum Industry Act in 2021, host communities have not experienced any positive change, rather have remained

Image
30-November-2023

Fidelity Bank Signs UN Principles for Responsible Banking

By Modupe Gbadeyanka A Nigerian lender, Fidelity Bank Plc, has agreed to adopt the single framework for a sustainable banking industry developed through collaboration between banks worldwide and the United Nations Environment Programme Finance Initiative (UNEP FI). Called the UN Principles for Responsible Banking (PRB), the initiative is a structure for ensuring that banks’ strategy and practices align with the vision society has set out for its future in the UN Sustainable Development Goals and the Paris Climate Agreement. Banks which have signed the principles commit to being ambitious in their sustainability strategies, working to mainstream and embed sustainability into

Image
30-November-2023

Morayo Afolabi-Brown Becomes TVC Entertainment Managing Director

By Modupe Gbadeyanka A popular talk show host, Mrs Morayo Afolabi-Brown, has been appointed as the Managing Director of TVC Entertainment (TVCe). The channel is the entertainment subsidiary of the Lagos-based broadcast media platform, TVC Communications. Mrs Afolabi-Brown is the co-anchor of the famous morning show on TVC, Your View, which has won several awards. Confirming her appointment on Thursday, she said, “I am excitingly pleased to announce my recent appointment as the Managing Director of TVCe, the Entertainment Channel of TVC Communications. “This is a new chapter in my career. I am exceedingly grateful to the board for entrusting

Image
30-November-2023

Tinubu Eyes Macroeconomic Stability, Better Investment Environment With 2024 Budget

By Aduragbemi Omiyale President Bola Tinubu has said the 2024 budget presented to the joint session of the National Assembly on Wednesday was designed to achieve macroeconomic stability, a better investment environment, greater access to social security, poverty reduction and enhanced human capital development. According to him, if these goals are achieved, the standard of living of Nigerians will improve and the citizens will enjoy the dividends of democracy. While presenting the 2024 Appropriation Bills to the parliament yesterday, the President said this was why he christened the budget proposal as the Budget of Renewed Hope. Mr Tinubu told the

Image
30-November-2023

FIRS Wants EFCC Backing to Track, Prosecute Tax Evaders, Others

By Modupe Gbadeyanka The chairman of the Federal Inland Revenue Service (FIRS), Mr Zacch Adedeji, has asked his counterpart in the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC), Mr Ola Olukoyede, to support his agency to achieve the Renewed Hope Agenda of President Bola Tinubu, who appointed both of them. Speaking during a courtesy visit to the headquarters of the anti-money laundering firm, Mr Adedeji said the EFCC has a role in ensuring that taxpayers’ funds are “judiciously utilised in line with the social contract with the people.” He assured that the FIRS would continue to strive to raise the revenue