Appeal Court Quashes Innoson’s Preliminary Objections Against GTBank

Image

By Dipo Olowookere

A Court of Appeal sitting in Enugu on Friday dismissed the preliminary objections brought before it by Chairman of Innoson Motors, Mr Innocent Chukwuma, and his company, Innoson Motors Ltd.

Innoson, arguing through his counsel, Prof. McCarthy Mbadugha, had at the last hearing of the matter on June 14, 2018 raised objections to a motion brought before the court by GTBank seeking to amend its notice of appeal before the court.

Delivering ruling yesterday, Justice Ogunwumiju held that the court would be in serious error if it decides to wait and hear Innoson Motors preliminary objection.

“There is no doubt that the application for amendment of the notice of appeal will, if successful, give the appeal a chance of being considered and disposed-off on the merit rather than on technicalities.

“It is implicit in the constitutional rights of fair hearing that parties in a case be accorded every reasonable opportunity of being heard, and that extends to the right to amend their processes and place before the court all the issues they may wish to canvass to enable the court reach a fair and just conclusion,” the judge held.

Justice Ogunwumiju also ruled that, “The fact that the respondent counsel raised objections to some of the grounds of appeal is not a bar that can deprive the appellant of the right to amend his notice of appeal.

“The respondent has not argued that the notice of appeal that the appellant is seeking to amend is fundamentally defective. He has failed to identify any substantial or legally acceptable reason to support the objection.

“There is no limitation of time to amend a notice of appeal, the objection by Innoson is not only frivolous but is vexatious and hereby dismissed.”

Concluding her ruling, Justice Ogunwumiju noted that “this court had at an earlier adjourned date observed that it found it strange that Innoson, a judgment creditor will be employing all manner of tactics to delay the hearing of the substantive appeal entered in this court as far back as 2013.”

“I see no reason to refuse the appellant’s (GTBank) request to amend its notice of appeal.

“Everyone in this judicial drama knows that the substantive appeal must be decided in this court and no matter how much time is wasted, the Supreme Court can only hear the substantive matter after it has been decided in this court.

“Without any disrespect to whatever legal gymnastics being displayed by the 1st to 4th Respondents’ (Innoson) Counsel, these are the types of practices that give the administration of Justice a bad name considering that this case involves money and has been hanging in this court since 2013.

“Considering all the reasons and circumstances set out above, I hold that it is in the interest of Justice that the appellants application be granted in terms of the following orders:

“Leave is granted to the Appellant (GTBank) to raise new issues in this appeal,

“Leave is granted to the Appellant (GTBank) to amend its notice of appeal in terms of the particulars and specifics highlighted in its supporting Affidavit

“The amended notice of appeal which has already been filed and served is properly filed and served

“Leave is granted the Appellant (GTBank) to amend its brief of argument to reflect the reliefs granted.”

Share
Related Stories
Image
01-December-2023

Nigeria Customs Service Develops App to Automate Transire

By Bliss Okperan The Tincan Island Port (TCIP) Command of the Nigeria Customs Service (NCS) has created a mobile application to automate its bond and license unit, Transire. At the unveiling of the app on Thursday, the Customs Area Controller, Comptroller Dera Nnadi, said the need to automate the Bond and License Unit had become imperative for administrative and procedural ease of doing business in the command. Speaking at a sensitization program on the automation process, Mr Nnadi informed participants that the application was developed by Superintendent of Customs Samuel Bello, to reduce the volumes of documents being deployed in

Image
07-December-2023

NUPRC Unveils Regulatory Framework for Energy Transition

By Adedapo Adesanya The Nigeria Upstream Petroleum Regulatory Commission (NUPRC) has unveiled the regulatory framework for energy transition, decarbonisation, and carbon monetization for upstream operations in Nigeria. The Commission Chief Executive, Mr Gbenga Komolafe, unveiled the regulatory framework at COP28 in Dubai, the United Arab Emirates (UAE) themed Driving Sustainable Upstream Operations to Achieve Just and Equitable Energy Transition.  Mr Komolafe noted that the regulatory framework has Natural Gas shift, zero routine gas flaring and methane abatement, carbon market development, and upstream operations efficiency as its key pillars. Others include technology and innovation, incentive mechanisms, collaboration, and risk management. According

Image
06-December-2023

Airtel Africa Advocates Enhanced PPP for Climate Action in Africa

By Modupe Gbadeyanka To achieve sustainable development in Africa, efforts must be made to have an enabling policy environment and collaboration between the government and the private sector. This was the submission of the chief executive of Airtel Africa, Mr Segun Ogunsanya, at a COP28 side event co-hosted by the telecommunications giant and the African Business Leaders Coalition (ABLC). Mr Ogunsanya, who is a member of the United Nations Global Compact’s ABLC, stressed that African business leaders and governments to join forces to advance sustainable growth, development, and prosperity across the continent. “We stress the importance of an enabling policy

More Stories
Image
11-October-2016

Protesters Demand Emefiele’s Resignation

By Ebitonye Akpodigha On Tuesday, October 11, 2016, some youths numbering about 100 stormed the headquarters of the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) in Abuja, demanding for the resignation of the Governor, Mr Godwin Emefiele. The demonstrators accused Mr Emefiele of failing to take Nigeria’s economy out of recession as well as stop the consistence weakening of the Naira against the Dollar and other top foreign currencies. On Tuesday, the Naira was exchanged at 310 against the Dollar at the interbank market, while it traded for 470 to a Dollar at the parallel market. The youths carried placards conveying various

Image
05-August-2017

Nigeria Already Exiting Recession—Budget Minister

By Dipo Olowookere Though the International Monetary Fund (IMF) says it doubts Nigeria will quit recession this year, Minister of Budget and National Planning, Mr Udo Udoma, has stressed that the country was already moving out of its economic crisis with the adoption of the Economic Recovery and Growth Plan (ERGP). Speaking on Thursday in Abuja while inaugurating the Joint Planning Committee for the 23rd Nigerian Economic Summit (NES), the Minister noted that the Federal Government was only concerned about sustaining the present positive momentum. In the last five months, inflation rate has been on a steady decline after it

Image
24-June-2019

Rumour and Propaganda are Negative to Abia Development

By Okechukwu Keshi Ukegbu Rumour and propaganda are serious antithesis to the development of a place. They are instruments usually deployed by debased minds and unscrupulous elements to achieve selfish ends. While rumour manifest in unfounded and unsubstantiated claims, half-truth, and outright lies, sometimes, propagandists manipulate these instruments to change and influence people’s beliefs, attitudes and perspective on issues and as a result persuade them to believe or see these as real. Rumours are assumptions or stories and statements in circulation without confirmation or certainty as to source or veracity. Rumours may or may not contain elements of truth, but

Image
15-October-2019

NSE Rules on Online Trading Portal Takes Effect October 21

By Dipo Olowookere The Nigerian Stock Exchange (NSE) on Tuesday, October 15, 2019, announced that the amendments made to two new rules recently approved by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) would become effective next week. In a notice to the market, the stock market regulator said Amendments to Dealing Members’ Rules Part IX-Rules on Online Trading Portas, which were approved by SEC on August 19, 2019, would take effect from Monday, October 21, 2019. Also, the Amendments to Dealing Members Rule 1.11 (Part XVII)-Dealing Member to Sponsor Application for Quotations, which was approved too on the same day, would

Image
01-June-2022

How Can Climate Change Impact Wildlife Conservation?

Climate change, to put it simply, will make wildlife conservation harder. With climate change, animals and plants throughout the world will be significantly impacted, which can cause the extinction of numerous species because they cannot find the basic necessities to live. Though there is a lot that conservation can do to help plants and animals, it’s going to be necessary to change and adapt as time goes by to keep up with climate change and the impact it will have. Some of the impacts climate change will have include; Animals Will Move Researchers are already seeing animals move further than

Image
04-October-2020

How COVID is Teaching us to be Better Communicators

By Olga Arara-Kimani After years of having served as a senior communications practitioner, I’ve learned that the most important attribute of any effective communicator is being able to look at yourself – your people and brands – through the lens of your most important stakeholders. When we do that, we can ask ourselves: what do I need to be doing to instil trust, to inspire, to energise, or to re-assure? Communications is essential to doing all of these things –more so during times of uncertainty. Amid the current pandemic, communicators need to intimately understand how perceptions and expectations of their

Image
17-October-2022

Active Voice Subscribers in Nigeria Now 206.45 million

By Adedapo Adesanya Nigeria’s active voice subscribers rose by 10.04 per cent to  206,449,125 in the second quarter of the year (Q2 2022) from the 187,611,501 recorded in the same period of 2021. The National Bureau of Statistics (NBS) said in its report titled NBS Telecoms Data: Active Voice and Internet per State, Porting and Tariff Information Report for Q2. The agency said that on a quarter-on-quarter basis, growth stood at 3.45 per cent, an increase from the 199,558,540 subscribers recorded in Q1. Also, the report revealed a total of 151,332,090 active internet subscribers were recorded in Q2 compared to

Image
13-April-2022

Standard Chartered Unveils $40m New Head Office in Zambia

By Modupe Gbadeyanka A new head office of Standard Chartered Bank in Zambia has been officially launched, with the commissioning carried out by the country’s President, Mr Hakainde Hichilema. The energy-efficient edifice located in the new business district of Lusaka, Zambia, is said to have gulped about $40 million. It is the first-ever EDGE certified building in Zambia. Mr Hichilema described the new head office as an immovable asset that becomes an integral part of the national balance sheet and underscores Standard Chartered Bank’s endurance, commitment and desire to build a better Zambia. In his speech, the Regional CEO of

Ad
Ad
Recent Stories
Image
09-December-2023

Moody’s Upgrades Nigeria’s Outlook to Positive After Economic Reforms

By Aduragbemi Omiyale Moody’s outlook on Nigeria has been upgraded from stable to positive after the federal government implemented a few economic reforms. In a statement on Friday, the rating agency said the decisions to remove the costly petrol subsidies, devaluation of the Naira and the unification of the foreign exchange (FX) market were good for the economy. When Mr Bola Tinubu assumed office in May 2023, he announced an end to the payment of subsidies on premium motor spirit (PMS). A month later, the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) announced the unification of the forex market, while the Naira

Image
09-December-2023

Value of Nigeria’s Unlisted Stock Exchange Reaches N1.2trn

By Adedapo Adesanya The NASD Over-the-Counter (OTC) Securities Exchange recorded a 1.6 per cent appreciation on Friday, December 8, as investors gained about N19.12 billion to push the valuation of the unlisted bourse to N1.202 trillion from the N1.182 trillion it closed in the preceding session. This achievement was influenced by the gains recorded by the trio of Aradel Holdings Plc, FrieslandCampina Wamco Nigeria Plc, and Central Securities Clearing System (CSCS) Plc. Data showed that Aradel Holdings Plc improved its value by N30 to settle at N900.00 per unit compared with the previous day’s N870.00 per unit, FrieslandCampina Wamco Nigeria

Image
09-December-2023

Naira Crashes to N1,099.05/$1 at Official Market

By Adedapo Adesanya The Nigerian Naira weakened to a new low on the American Dollar at the Nigerian Autonomous Foreign Exchange Market (NAFEM) on Friday, December 8, amid speculations that the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) has again devalued the local currency. In the previous trading session, there were reports that the exchange rate for clearing cargoes has been raised to N952/$1, sparking rumours that domestic currency would hit N1,000/$1 in the spot market. On the last trading session of the week, the Naira lost N255.98 or 30.4 per cent of its value on the greenback to trade at N1,099.05/$1

Image
09-December-2023

Nigerian Exchange Rises 0.12% Amid Weak Investor Sentiment

By Dipo Olowookere A 0.12 per cent appreciation was recorded by the Nigerian Exchange (NGX) Limited on Friday, reversing the previous day’s losses triggered by profit-taking in the banking sector. Business Post reports that it was the same banking space that influenced the growth posted yesterday, rising by 1.60 per cent, supported by the consumer goods indices, which appreciated by 0.15 per cent. However, there were pockets of profit-taking during the last trading session of the week, with the insurance sector shedding 0.78 per cent, the industrial goods sector losing 0.65 per cent, and the energy counter declining by 0.57

Image
09-December-2023

Crude Prices Up 2% on US Demand Growth Expectations

By Adedapo Adesanya Crude oil prices rose more than 2 per cent on Friday after data from the world’s largest oil producer, the United States, supported expectations of demand growth. Brent crude futures settled at $75.84 a barrel after chalking up $1.79 or 2.4 per cent, as the US West Texas Intermediate (WTI) crude futures traded at $71.23 after gaining $1.89 or 2.7 per cent. Despite the gain at the final session of the week, both benchmarks fell for a seventh straight week, their longest streak of weekly declines in half a decade, on lingering oversupply concerns. For the week,

Image
08-December-2023

PZ Cussons Nigeria Publishes List of 61,628 Shareholders With Unclaimed Dividends

By Aduragbemi Omiyale One of the players in the personal healthcare and consumer goods sectors, PZ Cussons Nigeria Plc, has published a list of its shareholders with unclaimed dividends. Unclaimed dividends are cash rewards given to investors, mainly from the profits from the company’s operations, but are yet to be collected by the beneficiaries. This has been a major source of sleepless nights for the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), which is working to bring down the number of unclaimed dividends. It has been reported that the value of unclaimed dividends in the nation’s stock market is over N185 billion.

Image
08-December-2023

CBN Raises Alarm on Fake Naira Notes, Threatens Prosecution

By Adedapo Adesanya The Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) has cautioned Nigerians to be wary of fake Naira notes currently in circulation, vowing to prosecute those engaged in the illicit acts. The apex bank in a release signed by Mrs Hakama Sidi Ali, the acting Director of Corporate Communications, said the counterfeit notes have been spread by some individuals for transactions in food markets and other places where commerce takes place across the country, noting that this is a punishable offence. “The attention of the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) has been drawn to the circulation of counterfeit banknotes, especially

Image
08-December-2023

Nigeria’s Crude Output Falls 30,000 Barrels Daily to 1.43mbpd in November

By Adedapo Adesanya Nigerian crude output fell by 30,000 barrels per day to 1.43 million barrels per day in November, according to data from an S&P Global Commodity Insight. This was lower than the 1.46 million barrels produced in October by Africa’s largest oil producer and 312,000 barrels per day short of its 1.742 million barrels per day target in 2023. Angola, Africa’s second-largest oil producer, saw output drop 20,000 barrels per day to 1.13 million barrels per day, according to the survey, compared with its quota of 1.46 million barrels per day. The drops impacted the wider output of

Image
08-December-2023

New Survey: Some Nigerian Bank Adverts Are Misleading—Customers

By Aduragbemi Omiyale Some aggrieved customers have accused Nigerian banks of lying about a few of their services in adverts in the media and not doing enough to assist when needed, despite using the provided platforms to lodge their complaints. In a survey conducted recently by a foremost perception consulting firm in the country, CMC Connect LLP, it was observed that some financial services consumers in Nigeria are not satisfied with what they get from their banks. The perception study carried out by the Strategy & Intelligence Service unit of CMC Connect showed that, “Consumers do not have enough information

Image
08-December-2023

Delta State Proposed Budget 2024 and Critical Concerns

By Jerome-Mario Utomi It is common knowledge that Delta State Governor, Sheriff Oborevwori, recently, presented a N714.4 billion Appropriation Bill tagged ‘Budget of Hope and Optimism,’ for the 2024 fiscal year to the state House of Assembly. What is, however, uncertain to Deltans and the watching world is whose interest the bill, if passed, is meant to serve or protect. There is also the concern as to whether it will herald into the political geography called Delta state, a just or an unjust law. As we are now, a just law is ‘a man-made code that squares with moral laws