By Modupe Gbadeyanka
All seems not to be too well with second tier banks in Nigeria, including Unity Bank, which has reportedly been in talks with investors since October.
According to a report by Bloomberg, analysts at Exotix Partners LLP, Jumai Mohammed and Ronak Gadhia said in a note last month that, “We view the Tier 2 banks as potentially challenged” because they seem unable “to weather asset-quality deterioration storms.”
Bloomberg said in its report published today titled ‘Nigeria Bank Divide Widens as Cash Shortage Chokes Small Lenders’ that small-and-medium sized lenders like Wema Bank Plc dropped plans last month to raise Dollar loans to rather sell Naira debt locally in smaller tranches.
Unity Bank Plc, which missed a February 28 central bank deadline to recapitalize, has been in talks with investors since October, while Diamond Bank Plc started negotiations to sell businesses and issue debt over a year ago.
The report quoted an analyst at Afrinvest West Africa Ltd, Omotola Abimbola, as saying “The gap between the Tier 1 and Tier 2 banks has been widening in profitability and balance-sheet size,” expressing fears that, “In the next one or two years, we will probably see the trend extending further.”
Below is Bloomberg’s report:
The divide between the haves and the have-nots among Nigerian banks is widening.
The country’s biggest lender is so flush with cash it plans to repay $400 million of bonds when they become due in November 2018 rather than raising additional debt, while the next two largest banks sold international bonds for the first time since 2014.
At the other end of the scale, smaller lenders are scrapping plans to raise dollar loans and struggling to find investors to raise capital.
Top tier banks in Africa’s most-populous nation and biggest oil producer are rallying after the central bank in April opened a foreign-exchange trading window, easing a crippling currency shortage that contributed to the worst economic contraction in 25 years.
Smaller banks are lagging behind as they battle rising levels of non-performing loans and capital buffers near regulatory minimums.
“The gap between the Tier 1 and Tier 2 banks has been widening in profitability and balance-sheet size,” said Omotola Abimbola, an analyst at Afrinvest West Africa Ltd. “In the next one or two years we will probably see the trend extending further.”
United Bank for Africa Plc, the third-biggest lender by market value, raised $500 million in its first Eurobond sale on June 1 at yields below initial guidance.
This followed an equivalent issue a week earlier by Zenith Bank Plc in a deal that was four times oversubscribed. Guaranty Trust Bank Plc, Nigeria’s largest lender, said this month it has no plans to sell Eurobonds because it’s setting aside funds to repay existing debt.
‘Potentially Challenged’
By contrast, small- and-medium sized lenders like Wema Bank Plc dropped plans last month to raise dollar loans to rather sell naira debt locally in smaller tranches. Unity Bank Plc, which missed a Feb. 28 central bank deadline to recapitalize, has been in talks with investors since October, while Diamond Bank Plc started negotiations to sell businesses and issue debt over a year ago.
“We view the Tier 2 banks as potentially challenged,” Exotix Partners LLP analysts Jumai Mohammed and Ronak Gadhia said in a note last month. The lenders seem unable “to weather asset-quality deterioration storms.”
Still, the five-year dollar bonds didn’t come cheap. Lagos-based United Bank for Africa settled on a coupon, or interest paid twice annually, of 7.75 percent. That’s the highest of at least 10 sales of $500 million by emerging-market banks this year from Turkey, Kuwait, Bahrain, South Korea and China. Zenith will pay 7.375 percent on the securities it placed, compared with 6.25 percent on five-year notes sold in April 2014.
Even so, more lenders will issue Eurobonds because they need dollars to offer loans in the U.S. currency or to repay debt, said Lekan Olabode, an analyst at Vetiva Capital Management Ltd. in Lagos. Lome, Togo-based Ecobank Transnational Inc. plans to sell a $400 million, 5-year convertible bond this month, which will be used to refinance debt and provide short-term bridge funding for non-performing loans at its Nigerian unit, its biggest business.
Margin Impact
Access Bank Plc has $350 million of bonds due in July, while Fidelity Bank Plc has to repay $300 million next May. “Any Eurobond issuance from the Tier 2 names will come in relatively more expensive — impacting margins,” Olabode said.
Some banks may use share-price gains to sell equity, although most trade at less than book value, making a rights offering expensive, he said. Local debt also comes at a price, with yields on 5-year government bonds at 16.3 percent.
The Nigerian Stock Exchange Banking Index has advanced 44 percent this year, with United Bank for Africa soaring 99 percent to its highest since January 2014, while Access Bank has climbed 83 percent to a four-year high. Wema has gained less than 2 percent and Skye Bank Plc and Union Bank of Nigeria Plc are up about 10 percent in 2017.
Union Bank, in which former Barclays Plc Chief Executive Officer Bob Diamond’s Atlas Mara Ltd. owns 31 percent, said in November it will sell as much as 50 billion naira ($156 million) in a rights issue. The sale is still scheduled to happen by the end of this quarter, spokeswoman Ogochukwu Ekezie-Ekaidem said on June 8.
Sterling Bank, which announced plans to raise 65 billion naira in Tier 2 capital last July, managed to raise 7.9 billion naira in 2016 at 16.5 percent, according to Chief Financial Officer Abubakar Suleiman. “We don’t think the market conditions are OK to raise it now, so we are waiting,’’ he said.
Without enough capital to back new business and write loans, small lenders risk falling further behind as Nigeria’s economy recovers from last year’s 1.6 percent contraction. The International Monetary Fund forecasts Nigeria will expand 0.8 percent this year as the oil price improves.
“Big banks have a pricing advantage,” said Olabode. “That makes a big difference in size and capacity to do business.”
Additional Information from Bloomberg
