Economy
Is Nigerian Equities Market Overvalued?
By Afrinvest Research
Given the challenges faced between H2:2014 and Q1:2017, investors constantly punished Nigerian equities, with sell-offs recorded across various sectors of the market.
Consequently, Nigerian equities were undervalued, in comparison to peers, presenting ample opportunities for investors to take advantage of some of the companies, which turned out impressive results despite the economic challenges.
Following the reforms in the FX market which resulted in increased FX liquidity and a restoration of investor confidence, massive gains were recorded in the market in 2017 and this has been sustained into 2018, up 12.2% (12/01/2018).
With the market now at an all-time high in terms of market capitalisation and the NSE All Share Index at a 9-year high, there are justifiable fears of overvaluation of the market which raises concerns with regards to a near term correction.
Our approach is to diagnose and probe into the fundamentals as well as technical merit of the overvaluation hypothesis.
From our analysis, average Trailing P/E and P/BV for the Nigerian equities market in the last one month as at 17/01/2018 stood at 13.1x and 1.7x, which are lower than 15.1x and 2.0x respectively for the MSCI Frontier markets index.
Looking back to the last 2-year bull market run Nigeria experienced between 2012 and 2013, the Nigerian equities market was priced at a premium to frontier markets peers in the late cycle of the run, as shown in the average P/E and P/BV multiples of the MSCI Frontier Markets index of 12.5x and 1.6x in 2013 relative to 13.5x and 2.2x of the Nigerian market in the same period.
This implies that despite the rally in the market in 2017 and early trading in 2018, current undervaluation of the Nigerian market by valuation multiples and the proven historical valuation premium Nigerian market enjoys in period of boom suggest there are more miles to clock in the market rally.
Hence, against the backdrop of improving macroeconomic conditions as well as positive outlook for corporate earnings, we believe there is a compelling case for investors to sustain interest in the Nigerian equities market as already noticed in the YTD return of 17.4% (17/01/2018).
Our Scenario Analysis in 2018
A review of our market forecast for 2017, shows that actual performance outperformed our bull case scenario, in which we projected that a contraction in the spread between the official and parallel market rates, an increase in oil production to about 2.2mb/d, oil prices between $55/b to $60/b and MPR at 14.0% will result in a 15.6% appreciation in the benchmark index.
Actual performance for 2017 (+42.3%) surpassed our forecast as investor confidence was reinvigorated following the reforms in the FX market and resilient earnings. In 2018, we envisage that market performance will be largely determined by the following factors:
- Earnings fundamental of Corporates;
- Stability in the FX market and other macro indicators; and
- Funds flow dynamics to emerging and frontier markets.
Our analysis of market trend over the past 10 years, makes a case for a possible repetition of history.
As noticed in 2012 and 2013, the periods following the global economic crisis, sentiment in the local bourse strengthened which drove the ASI 35.4% and 47.2% northwards in the respective years.
In a similar situation, as the economy rebounded from the slump – 2014 to 2016 – in 2017, we expect market sentiment to wax stronger in 2018.
In our scenario analysis for the market performance in 2018, we employed a blend of relative valuation in which we benchmarked our market valuation against multiples for peers in the MSCI Frontier market index and absolute valuation based on price forecasts for our coverage universe which is about 86.0% of the entire market.
From our analysis, the Nigerian market has outperformed the MSCI index on the basis of EPS, growing at a CAGR of 12.2% between 2010 and 2017 vs. a 2.1% decline for the MSCI index in the same period.
Similarly, on a P/E basis, the Nigerian market has commanded higher pricing over the MSCI index in 6 of the 8 years under review.
Against this backdrop, we carried out scenario analysis for the performance of the All Share Index in 2018.
Our forecast for the performance of the benchmark index in 2018 is largely positive as our scenarios (bear, base, bull) all signal appreciation in the benchmark index.
On a relative valuation basis, we noted earlier that our expectations for corporate earnings in 2018 is largely optimistic on the back of improving conditions in the operating environment; hence, we assumed an EPS of N3,377.4 as our base case scenario which implies a 13.0% increase from a trailing EPS of N2,988.8 in the prior year.
Our EPS projection was based on the 7-year EPS CAGR for the All Share Index to arrive at the forecast.
For our P/E projection, we compared current pricing in the Nigerian markets against peers for which the MSCI Frontier Markets index was employed.
In order to arrive at our p/e forecast of 14.1x in the base case scenario, we analysed historical P/E multiple of the ASI relative to the MSCI Frontier Index P/E and assumed a 1.0x premium in line with historical valuation spread.
This methodology yielded an All Share Index projection of 47,620.71 points in our base case scenario, which suggests a 24.5% appreciation in the year.
On an absolute valuation basis, we have a more conservative forecast for market performance, albeit still positive.
Based on our 12-month target prices from our coverage universe of stocks – about 86.0% of market cap – relative to 2017 yearend prices, we forecast a 5.6% jump in market capitalisation, implying ASI projection of 40,384.81 points.
Finally, to make a call on market performance for 2018, we adopted a blend of both valuation methodologies. Based on the foregoing, we arrived at an ASI projection of 45,811.73 points for 2018 which is a 19.8% appreciation from 38,243.19 points in 2017.
Our bear case (+7.7% to 41,189.9 points) and bull case (+32.7% to 50,749.10 points) also follow the same trend and further buttress the consensus view of positive market performance in 2018.
Whilst we note that developments in the macro space will also determine overall market performance, we opine that barring any major shocks in the FX market, corporate fundamentals will be a key determinant of overall performance.
By Dipo Olowookere
About 0.04 per cent was recovered on Friday from the loss recorded by the Nigerian Exchange (NGX) the previous due to profit-taking.
Yesterday, investors were in the market with renewed vigour, mopping up stocks trading at relatively cheaper prices.
According to data, the insurance counter gained 0.41 per cent, the banking sector appreciated by 0.38 per cent, and the consumer goods index grew by 0.14 per cent.
The gains achieved by these three sectors were enough to lift Customs Street at the close of business despite the 0.26 per cent decline printed by the industrial goods segment and the 0.14 per cent loss suffered by the energy industry. The commodity counter was flat during the session.
A total of 43 equities gained weight on the last trading day of this week, while 26 equities shed weight, indicating a positive market breadth index and strong investor sentiment.
Red Star Express increased its share price by 10.00 per cent to N13.20, NCR Nigeria grew by 9.97 per cent to N128.55, SCOA Nigeria inflated by 9.96 per cent to N14.90, Omatek appreciated by 9.94 per cent to N1.77, and Deap Capital expanded by 9.85 per cent to N4.46.
On the flip side, McNichols decreased by 8.81 per cent to N6.00, Legend Internet crumbled by 7.56 per cent to N5.50, Cornerstone Insurance crashed by 6.48 per cent to N6.35, C&I Leasing contracted by 6.29 per cent to N8.20, and Austin Laz slipped by 5.78 per cent to N3.75.
Yesterday, 539.9 million shares valued at N16.7 billion were transacted in 48,023 deals versus the 1.0 billion shares worth N31.6 billion executed in 51,227 deals in the preceding day, implying a shrink in the trading volume, value, and number of deals by 46.01 per cent, 47.15 per cent, and 6.26 per cent apiece.
Zenith Bank was the most active for the day with 54.6 million stocks sold for N3.8 billion, Jaiz Bank traded 41.5 million units worth N359.4 million, Secure Electronic Technology transacted 37.7 million units valued at N39.2 million, Access Holdings exchanged 30.5 million units for N699.2 million, and Lasaco Assurance transacted 27.2 million units worth N68.3 million.
When the market closed for the day, the All-Share Index (ASI) went up by 72.21 points to 166,129.50 points from 166,057.29 points and the market capitalisation gained N31 billion to N106.354 trillion from N106.323 trillion.
By Adedapo Adesanya
It was a positive ending for the Naira this week after it further appreciated against the US Dollar in the Nigerian Autonomous Foreign Exchange Market (NAFEX) on Friday, January 16 by N1.33 or 0.09 per cent to sell for N1,417.95/$1 compared with the previous day’s N1,419.28/$1.
The domestic currency also gained N2.41 against the Euro in the official market to close at N1,647.51/€1 versus the preceding session’s closing price of N1,649.92/€1, however, it suffered a N7.97 loss against the Pound Sterling in the same market window to trade at N1,901.32/£1, in contrast to Thursday’s closing price of N1,893.35/£1.
In the same vein, the Nigerian Naira depleted against the Dollar at the GTBank FX counter by N2 to quote at N1,427/$1 compared with the previous day’s N1,425/$1, but strengthened against the greenback at the black market yesterday by N5 to settle at N1,485/$1 versus the N1,490/$1 it was exchanged a day earlier.
Improved supply conditions helped keep the market within range as exporters’ and importers’ inflows in addition to non-bank corporate supply enhanced liquidity as the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) made no visible intervention.
Stronger external inflows from foreign portfolio investors (FPIs) and improving current account dynamics, continue to align with structural support in the wider economy.
Nigeria has seen projections of a stronger economic or gross domestic product (GDP) growth and lower inflation in 2026, with these forecasts citing improved macroeconomic fundamentals and reform impacts.
As for the cryptocurrency market, it was mixed following selloff in precious metals and lower US stocks appeared to be denting crypto sentiment.
Gold and silver, both of which also enjoyed big rallies earlier this week, tumbled 1.2 per cent and 5 per cent, respectively while key US stock indexes — the Nasdaq, S&P 500 and Dow Jones Industrial Average — all reversed from early gains to modest losses in Friday trade.
Dogecoin (DOGE) shrank by 2.2 per cent to $0.1370, Ripple (XRP) slipped by 0.8 per cent to $2.05, Ethereum (ETH) went down by 0.7 per cent to $3,228.56, and Bitcoin (BTC) slumped by 0.6 per cent to $95,086.80.
Conversely, Litecoin (LTC) appreciated by 3.2 per cent to $74.48, Solana (SOL) rose by 0.4 per cent to $143.70, Cardano (ADA) jumped by 0.2 per cent to $0.3942, and Binance Coin (BNB) increased by 0.1 per cent to $935.88, while the US Dollar Tether (USDT) and the US Dollar Coin (USDC) remained unchanged at $1.00 each.
By Adedapo Adesanya
Oil prices settled higher amid lingering worries about a possible US military strike against Iran, a decision that may still occur over the weekend.
Brent crude settled at $64.13 a barrel after going up by 37 cents or 0.58 per cent and the US West Texas Intermediate (WTI) crude finished at $59.44 a barrel after it gained 25 cents or 0.42 per cent.
The US Navy’s aircraft carrier USS Abraham Lincoln was expected to arrive in the Persian Gulf next week after operating in the South China Sea.
Market analysts noted that it doesn’t seem likely anything will happen soon. However, the weekends have become the perfect time for actions so as not offset the markets.
The market had risen after protests flared up in Iran and US President Donald Trump signalled the potential for military strikes, but lost over 4 per cent on Thursday as the American president said Iran’s crackdown on the protesters was easing, allaying concerns of possible military action that could disrupt oil supplies.
Iran produces approximately 3.2 million barrels per day, accounting for roughly 4 per cent of global crude production, so it was not a coincidence that markets rallied sharply through Tuesday and Wednesday as President Trump canceled meetings with Iranian officials and posted that “help is on its way” to Iranian protesters, raising fears of potential US military strikes that sent prices surging toward multi-month highs.
Weighing against those fears are potential supply increases from Venezuela.
The Trump administration is exploring plans to swap heavy Venezuelan crude for US medium sour barrels that can actually go straight into Strategic Petroleum Reserve (SPR) caverns, since not all all oil belongs in the reserve.
According to Reuters, the Department of Energy is considering moving Venezuelan heavy crude into commercial storage at the Louisiana Offshore Oil Port, while US producers deliver medium sour crude into the SPR in exchange.
Analysts expect higher supply this year, potentially creating a ceiling for the geopolitical risk premium on prices.
Some investors covered short positions ahead of the three-day Martin Luther King holiday weekend in the US.
-
Feature/OPED6 years agoDavos was Different this year
-
Travel/Tourism9 years ago
Lagos Seals Western Lodge Hotel In Ikorodu
-
Showbiz3 years agoEstranged Lover Releases Videos of Empress Njamah Bathing
-
Banking8 years agoSort Codes of GTBank Branches in Nigeria
-
Economy3 years agoSubsidy Removal: CNG at N130 Per Litre Cheaper Than Petrol—IPMAN
-
Banking3 years agoFirst Bank Announces Planned Downtime
-
Banking3 years agoSort Codes of UBA Branches in Nigeria
-
Sports3 years agoHighest Paid Nigerian Footballer – How Much Do Nigerian Footballers Earn