Senate and Local Government Autonomy

Image

By Jerome-Mario Chijioke Utomi

Among so many bills recently passed or still working on by the nation’s Senate in the ongoing constitution amendment. This piece is particularly struck by the passage of the local government financial, administrative autonomy bill which among other provisions seeks that each local government council to creates and maintain its own special account to be called Local Government Allocation Account into which all the allocations will be paid.

Aside from seeking to grant full financial and administrative autonomy to local governments, the bills seek to amend the Constitution to repeal the state joint local government account and provide for a special account where all allocations due to the local government councils, from the federation account and state government, shall be paid.

While this development is welcomed and applauded, there is a lot that is wrong with the local government system in Nigeria, and unless all those wrongs are examined critically and remedies applied to them, it can only create more problems. Guiding against that, via timely corrective action before it happens is the objective of this piece.

Take as an illustration, apart from the fact that well foresighted Nigerians have in the past argued that to free local councils from the clutches of the state governors and ensure credible elections into local councils, the power to appoint chairpersons and commissioners of the state electoral bodies should be removed from the state governors, the global community, especially development-based groups and elections observers, do not think that what Nigeria is doing is the best way to organize elections be it at federal, states or local government levels as governments actions often fail to meet the four basic conditions necessary to create an enabling environment for holding of free and fair elections.

These conditions they noted include; an honest, competent and non-partisan body to administer the election, the knowledge and willingness of the political community to accept basic rules and regulations governing the contest for power, a developed system of political parties and teams of candidates presented to the electorates as alternative choices. And an independent judiciary to interpret electoral laws and settle election disputes.

Such worries partly explain the inertia and damning/reports that trail every election in the country monitored by international observers. Local governments and elections say a recent report, are two essential features of modern democracies. They help to establish, nurture and sustain democracy and democratic political culture. Elections provide the electorate with the power to freely participate in choosing their leaders and in providing the much-needed support and legitimacy to the state. Yet, its electoral approach/process has become curiously old fashioned and derogates the sanctity of elections as an institutional mechanism for conferring political power on citizens in a democratic dispensation.

This claim is supported by many facts. In the accounts by Massoud Omar, Department of Local Government and Development Studies, Institute of Administration, Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria, Nigeria, credible elections into local government councils have been non-existent since independence in 1960 till date. This is because the local councils are often subjected to controls by the upper levels of government in the federal system of government.

During the First Republic, the native authorities (as local governments were then called) were under the control of the regional governments. The Constitution of the Second Republic (1979-1983) gave state governors the power to dissolve local councils and appoint Caretaker Committees to run the affairs of local councils.

‘The 1999 Constitution currently being operated empowers state governors to appoint chairpersons of State Independent Electoral Commissions, the electoral umpires mandated to conduct local government elections in the 36 states of the federation.

As the situation stands, there is some ambiguity as to whether the state governors can dissolve local councils before elections are conducted at the expiration of their tenure, but often, state governors capitalise on this ambiguity to dissolve local councils at the end of their tenure and appoint Caretaker Committees. Often, these Committees are staffed with cronies and party sympathisers’.

Anambra State is a vivid example of a state where Caretaker Committees took charge of local council affairs for about 10 years under four successive governors – Chris Ngige, Peter Obi, Andy Uba and Virginia Etiaba and again Peter Obi who towards the end of his administration organized election on January 11, 2014.

Those elected have since vacated their positions since 2016. As of the time of filing this report, no local council elections have been held in the state since the dissolution under Governor Willy Obiano’s led administration.

Similarly, in most states where local government elections seem to have been held, there appears no remarkable difference between such a result and that of a one-party affair.

According to a commentator, it amounts to the “selection” and “appointment” of local representatives because state governors use the incumbency factor to rig elections in favour of their preferred candidates.

Situations, where local councils are controlled by opposition parties, are rare, and where this happens, the local councils are dissolved and caretaker committees, often made up of sympathizers of the ruling party, are appointed in their place.

Even though it cannot be characterized as an impossibility that a party at some points swept (wins) all the local council positions in a state, analysts are particularly worried about the frequency and disturbed by the accompanying belief that the main reason for this trend of affairs is that whoever controls the local councils is sure to gain control of the state government during gubernatorial elections.

To change this narrative in ways that will guarantee true autonomy for the local government areas, the following steps need to be taken; first is the need to recognize that three electoral laws govern the process of electing people into political offices. They include The Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1999, The Electoral Act 2010; and The INEC Regulations and Guidelines for the Conduct of Elections, 2019.

From the above, supervision of Election- Section 78 of the Constitution provides that the registration of voters and the conduct of elections shall be subject to the direction and supervision of the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC).

Secondly, Part One of the Electoral Act also provides that each State of the Federation and Federal Capital Territory, must establish an INEC office which shall perform functions that will be assigned to it from time to time by the commission, and any person appointed to the office shall be answerable to the commission and will hold office for five years. This provision is made under Section 6 of the Act.

The Act also provides under Section 9 that the Commission (INEC) shall compile, maintain and update continuously a National Register of Voters for each State and the Federal Capital Territory and Local Government, which will include the names of all persons entitled to vote in any Federal, State, Local Government or Area Council elections in Nigeria.

In the face of all these provisions/responsibilities performed by INEC at both state and local government levels, won’t it be considered as wisdom if the Electoral Act is again amended to allow/empower INEC to handle local council elections in the country since they already exist in, and capped with the information/data of all the electorates in the 36 states/FCT and in all the 774 Local Government Areas in the country? The reason is predicated on the argument that in the past two decades of its existence; INEC may not have performed perfectly well.

However, if its performance is juxtaposed with experiences Nigerians have suffered in the hands of the States Independent Electoral Commission that of INEC will be judged a Child’s play.

Utomi Jerome-Mario is the Programme Coordinator (Media and Public Policy), Social and Economic Justice Advocacy (SEJA), a Lagos-based non-governmental organization (NGO). He can be reached via [email protected]/08032725374

Share
Related Stories
Image
28-February-2024

Zero Routine Gas Flares and Delta Communities

By Jerome-Mario Utomi It is common knowledge that in pursuit of meeting the targets of 20 per cent (unconditional) and 47 per cent (conditional) greenhouse gas emission reduction as contained in the Nationally Determined Contribution under the Paris Accord reportedly signed by the President Bola Tinubu administration, the Nigerian National Petroleum Company Limited/TotalEnergies joint venture recently achieved zero routine gas flare in all its assets. While it is obvious that “the significance of this achievement is that the last routine flare volume of about 12MMscf/d (12 million standard cubic feet per day) of gas has now been eliminated giving rise

Image
14-March-2024

How Business Can Build Future Career Paths for Women in AI, Emerging Tech

The underrepresentation of women in the Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics (STEM) fields continues to persist.  This is despite progress being made in gender equality and equity over the last decade, According to the latest UNESCO report on gender-responsive education, too many girls and women are held back by biases, social norms and expectations influencing the quality of the education they receive and the subjects they study. Girls are particularly under-represented in developing countries in the African continent; particularly around STEM education and, consequently, in STEM careers. This gender disparity is alarming, especially as STEM careers are the jobs of the future.

Image
08-March-2024

Improving Productivity and Efficiency in SMEs

By Emmanuel Otori Running a small and medium business is not always an easy ride, especially in an unpredictable business environment. These businesses always seek ways to stay afloat and the only way to do this is to implement strategies that can increase productivity and efficiency. Most Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs) are one-man types of businesses with few employees on the ground to run the affairs of the business. Usually, SMEs’ business infrastructures are limited and they have to take one step at a time to grow their business. Many reports show that at least 80 per cent of SMEs

More Stories
Image
15-February-2019

Nigerian Breweries to Pay N1.83k Per Share Dividend Amid 41% Drop in PAT

By Modupe Gbadeyanka The 2018 financial year was not too good for Nigerian Breweries, going by details of its financial results released on the Nigerian Stock Exchange (NSE). The results, posted on the NSE website on Friday, showed that profit posted by the brewery firm went down by 41.2 percent when compared with the 2017 financial year. It was disclosed that the profit after tax depreciated to N19.4 billion from N33 billion, while the profit before tax declined to N29.4 billion from N46.6 billion a year earlier. Also, the total revenue generated by the company in the 2018 financial year

Image
06-September-2017

APC Group Warns Critics to “Leave Aisha Alone”

By Dipo Olowookere A group known as APC Youths Renaissance has warned those it called “political detractors” to leave Minister of Women Affairs, Mrs Aisha Alhassan, alone. This followed a video making the rounds showing the Minister endorsing the 2019 presidential ambition of former Vice President, Mr Atiku Abubakar. In a statement signed by its National Secretary, Mr Collins Edwin, the group said it was wrong to accuse Mrs Alhassan of disloyalty to the present administration of President Muhammadu Buhari. In the statement, the APC group said Mr Buhari would have been very suspicious of Mrs Alhassan if she had

Image
13-June-2020

OPEC Panel to Meet Next Week to Review Oil Market

By Adedapo Adesanya A panel of the Organisation of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) will meet next week, June 18 to review the oil market and advise the wider OPEC+ group cooperating on a record supply cut. OPEC, Russia and allies, known as OPEC+, agreed last Saturday to keep production cuts of 9.7 million barrels per day or 10 percent of pre-coronavirus world demand until the end of July. The reduction has helped oil prices to more than double since April when prices plunged. To step up consultations on the effectiveness of the agreement, OPEC+ also agreed that a panel

Image
23-April-2022

Market Extends Rally by 0.49% as Oando Emerges Highest Price Gainer

By Dipo Olowookere Oando Plc closed Friday’s session on the floor of the Nigerian Exchange (NGX) Limited as the highest price gainer after its equity value rose by 9.94 per cent to N5.86. The news that the energy firm was holding a board meeting to consider its financial statements may have triggered a renewed interest in the company’s equities, causing the stock market to extend its rally by 0.49 per cent at the close of transactions. Business Post reports that a total of 36 shares appreciated in value yesterday as Eterna gained 9.92 per cent to trade at N6.65, Meyer

Image
01-March-2021

Most Insightful Types of Eyelashes Boxes

If you’re running a cosmetic business, you can manufacture these boxes to impress your customers and to extend your sales. These boxes are created with the client’s favoured packaging material and also the involved whole brand is imprinted on them. Dreamy, supernatural eyes with a flutter of luscious eyelashes are solely found within the novels. In reality, not everyone’s endowed with the long, thick lash line. Similar to makeup is employed to reinforce your options; false eyelashes are accustomed to creating your eyes look sound. There are such a big amount of brands and kinds of eyelashes obtainable within the market, it may be confusing finding the proper one for you. Material, shape, thickness, and length are vital factors

Image
24-August-2020

Cross River Decries Exclusion from 13% Derivation

By Adedapo Adesanya The Cross River State Government has lamented its exclusion from the 13 per cent oil derivation given to oil-producing states in the country following the loss of her oil wells after the Bakassi Peninsula was ceded to Cameroon. As of now, only nine states in Nigeria – Delta, Akwa-Ibom, Bayelsa, Rivers, Edo, Ondo, Imo, Abia and Lagos get the agreed derivation from the monthly Federation Account Allocation Committee (FAAC). Governor of Cross River State, Mr Ben Ayade, said the state has been like a weeping child in the Niger Delta Development Commission (NDDC) since the Bakassi issue.

Image
17-March-2019

NIMASA Wants Fixed Fire-Fighting Systems on Fishing Vessels

By Dipo Olowookere The Nigerian Maritime Administration and Safety Agency (NIMASA) has said it would recommend fishing vessels on the nation’s territorial waters to have fixed fire-fighting systems. Head of Maritime Safety and Seafarers Standards Department at NIMASA, Captain Sunday Umoren, dropped this hint while reacting to reports that the agency failed to provide assistance to a distressed fishing vessel; MV ORC4, resulting in the sinking of the vessel and loss of lives. In a statement issued on the matter, NIMASA said it actually saved the vessel through its Search and Rescue Operations alongside the Nigerian Liquefied Natural Gas company

Image
18-July-2018

T-Bills Market Stays Bullish as Money Market Rates Drop on Reduced Funding Pressures

By Dipo Olowookere Activities in the treasury bills market remained bullish on Tuesday like in the previous session. Business Post reports that this was supported by buoyant system liquidity and demand from investors looking to reinvest bond coupon payments in the interim as yields continue to adjust to local and international headwinds. According to analysts at Zedcrest Research, discount rates compressed by about 0.24 percent across the trading benchmark securities, with majority of the demand witnessed on the short to medium end of the curve. This trend is expected to continue in the interim, barring any liquidity management action by

Ad
Ad
Recent Stories
Image
19-March-2024

TikTok, AU Commission Partner for Digital Safety Campaign

By Adedapo Adesanya TikTok and the African Union Commission (AUC) are teaming up to launch the Africa-wide #SaferTogether Campaign, aimed at educating and engaging youngsters, parents, teachers, and community leaders on digital safety through in-app and on-ground activities. The partnership will be carried out by a short-form video app and the African Union Commission’s Women, Gender, and Youth Directorate (WGYD) and is aimed at bolstering online safety awareness among the youth as well as parents, teachers and guardians in Africa. This innovative collaboration emerges at a critical moment, addressing the urgent need for digital safety amidst the unique challenges faced

Image
19-March-2024

Court Dismisses Olu Agunloye’s EFCC Abuse Suit, Orders N500,000 Payment

By Adedapo Adesanya The Federal High Court in Abuja has dismissed a suit filed by a former Minister of Power and Steel, Mr Olu Agunloye, alleging abuse of his fundamental rights and seeking to be shielded from investigation and prosecution by the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC). In a statement following the court’s judgement on Monday, the anti-graft agency said the presiding judge, Mr Obiora Egwuatu, dismissed the suit for lacking in merit and awarded a cost of N500,000 against Mr Agunloye in favour of the EFCC. Dismissing the suit, the judge held that Mr Agunloye’s fundamental human right

Image
19-March-2024

International Breweries Wants Approval for $379.9m Loan, Convert to Equity

By Aduragbemi Omiyale An Extra-ordinary General Meeting (EGM) for shareholders of International Breweries Plc to approve the $379.9 million loan to the company from AB InBev Nigeria Holdings BV and convert this to equity is scheduled for Tuesday, April 9, 2024. This was confirmed by a statement signed by the company secretary, Mrs Marian Reginald-Ukwuoma, on Monday. It was disclosed that the meeting would take place at the External Ballroom of the Federal Palace Hotel in Lagos. Business Post gathered that International Breweries obtained a loan of $379.9 million from Citibank Abu Dhabi and AB InBev Nigeria, one of the

Image
19-March-2024

How Putin Won March 2024 Presidential Election

By Kestér Kenn Klomegâh After three days (March 15 to 17) of voting, Vladimir Putin is leading the Russian presidential election with 87.34% after 98% of ballots were counted, according to data from the Russian Central Elections Commission. Undoubtedly it gives Putin, who has been in power since the last days of 1999, another six-year term (2024-2030) to lead Russia, and to pursue with much vigour its foreign policy ambitions in the international system and push forward the much-trumpeted multipolar configuration with a focus on Global South. Putin’s assertive control over the political landscape has been solidified due to the

Image
19-March-2024

Moove Raises $100m in Fresh Race to Conquer New Markets

By Adedapo Adesanya Exactly a year after raising $105 million in an oversubscribed Series A2 round, African mobility company, Moove, has raised $100 million in a Series B funding round as it plots expansion into new markets. According to reports, the funding round was led by mobility giant, Uber and saw injection from others such as sovereign wealth fund Mubadala, The Latest Ventures, AfricInvest, Palm Drive Capital, Triatlum Advisors, and Future Africa. This now pushes Moove’s post-money valuation to $750 million. The company is helping to solve the continent’s acute problem of limited access to vehicle financing for millions of

Image
19-March-2024

Oil Stocks Trigger 1.77% Gain at NASD OTC Exchange

By Adedapo Adesanya Oil stocks, Aradel Holdings and Acorn Petroleum, led the NASD Over-the-Counter (OTC) Securities Exchange to a 1.77 per cent appreciation on Monday, March 18. They increased the value of the alternative bourse by N24.85 billion during the trading session to N1.428 trillion from the N1.403 trillion it closed in the preceding, and the NASD Unlisted Security Index (NSI) rose by 18.33 points to wrap the session at 1,053.98 points compared with 1,035.65 points recorded at the previous session. Aradel Holdings Plc, after recent profit taking, appreciated by N114.28 yesterday to settle at N1,734.28 per unit compared with last

Image
19-March-2024

Naira Trades N1,597/$1 at Official Market, N1,600/$1 at Black Market

By Adedapo Adesanya The Naira appreciated against the US Dollar at the Nigerian Autonomous Foreign Exchange Market (NAFEM) segment of the currency market on Monday by 0.3 per cent or N5.41 to close at N1,597.34/$1 compared with last Friday’s value of N1,602.75/$1. It also improved its value against the Pound Sterling in the official market yesterday by N50.97 to wrap the session at N2,003/£1 compared with the preceding session’s N2,054.06/£1 and gained N41.89 against the Euro to close at N1,712.69/€1 versus N1,754.58/€1. It was observed that the supply of forex, according to data from the FMDQ Securities Exchange, slightly waned

Image
19-March-2024

Brent Jumps to $86 Per Barrel on Low Crude Exports, Stronger Demand

By Adedapo Adesanya  The price of the international crude benchmark, Brent Crude, rose by 88 cents or 1.0 per cent to $86.22 per barrel on Monday, triggered by lower crude exports from Iraq and Saudi Arabia and signs of stronger demand and economic growth in China and the US. Also, the US West Texas Intermediate (WTI) crude appreciated by $1.01 or 1.3 per cent to $82.05 per barrel, as Iraq, the second-largest producer in the Organisation of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC), said it would reduce crude exports to 3.3 million barrels a day in the coming months to compensate

Image
18-March-2024

Cardoso Begins CBN Clean-up, Removes Directors Close to Emefiele

By Aduragbemi Omiyale There are strong indications that some directors at the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) may have to lose their jobs in the in-house clean-up exercise by the Governor, Mr Yemi Cardoso. Reports suggest that Mr Cardoso wants to let go of some directors who worked closely with Mr Godwin Emefiele, who President Bola Tinubu believes worked to stop him from going to Aso Rock. Recall that during his electioneering campaign, Mr Tinubu accused the former CBN chief and some persons of introducing the botched Naira redesign policy to frustrate him. Immediately after he assumed office on May

Image
18-March-2024

Profit-Taking Depletes Nigerian Exchange by 0.40%

By Dipo Olowookere The Nigerian Exchange (NGX) Limited succumbed to profit-taking on Monday, shedding 0.40 per cent despite a bullish investor sentiment. The local bourse ended with 27 price gainers and 18 price losers today, implying a positive market breadth index. The selling pressure was just investors booking profit after gains in the past few trading sessions, especially in MTN Nigeria, GTCO, Zenith Bank and others. The heaviest price depreciation was recorded by McNichols, 9.30 per cent, closing at N1.17, and was trailed by DAAR Communications, which shed 8.97 per cent to 71 Kobo. UPDC declined by 7.89 per cent