Why Power Sector Privatisation in Nigeria has Failed—Egbin Power Chairman


**Targets 5000MW Generation in 5 Years

By Dipo Olowookere

Egbin Power Plc is the largest privately owned power generation company in Sub-Saharan Africa and accounts for over 20 percent of power generated in Nigeria.

In this interview, Mr Kola Adesina, Chairman, Egbin Power Plc speaks about the firm’s experience post privatisation, expansion plans and other issues in the nation’s power sector.

The new management took over the affairs of Egbin in November 2013. Where is the company today in its post-privatization plan

Despite these challenges, we have achieved and exceeded our post-privatization targets. From less than 400MWs, Egbin is generating 1,100 MW and shall hit 1,320 MWs in April 2018. Ordinarily, about 220MW that we began to overhaul should have been back since last year if the N140 Billion we are being owed by NBET had been paid. Now, we are struggling to ramp up our capacity because of liquidity challenges and growing and unsustainable debt. Evacuation of the electricity we generate has been a challenge too. Today, the plant can generate about 1,100MWs, but we cannot evacuate more than 600 MWs, because of frequency issues from the transmission end of the sector. The Transmission Company of Nigeria says the DISCOs are not receiving power. Therefore, they have to drop the load. For Egbin to break even and continue to operate well, we should be evacuating a minimum of 800 MWs every day.

What have you achieved so far

It has not been all smooth sailing. I make bold to say that Egbin has raised the performance bar in the sector through continuing investments in human capital and infrastructure resulting in ongoing drive for sustainable performance and expansion. We have had to contend with policy summersault and operational challenges occasioned by defaults in contractual obligations from Day One, the absence of a cost reflective regime, FOREX variance of over N200 per naira and inflation rate that rose from 8% at takeover to 18-19%, as well as debts owed to us by Nigerian Bulk Electricity Trader, NBET. Therefore, the considerable improvement Egbin has made, using the loan acquired in dollars to provide the infrastructure to generate the electricity, appears lost, because the company has not been able to recover its cost. The loan was in dollars, but power tariff is in the local currency. Therefore, what Egbin has lost between the time of acquisition and today is so depressing. The company has lost over 200% from each Naira invested in the acquisition of the plant. However, we remain committed to the project of lighting up Nigeria, this is what motivated our acquisition bid and we will most certainly surpass our targets ultimately.

How do you deal with debts owed by government agencies

Ordinarily, that’s simple! Just ask all MDAs to have prepaid meters. With that, those that have credits on their meters would have electricity. Once the credit is exhausted and no replenishment, then no electricity. I believe the government is doing its best in terms of getting the MDAs debts settled, but they can still do more to support a metering arrangement that will make payment by the MDAs seamless whilst accelerating ongoing efforts at settling the legacy debts. The DISCOs who have so much odds stacked against them also have debts to settle under a system where all the performance enablers have not been provided. The same DISCOs would be told not to raise the tariff beyond a certain threshold when you know the critical parameters that produce the tariff are not right, and as such the real tariff is not being charged. Yet, the authorities and all stakeholders acknowledge that money is required to upgrade the transformers, restructure the distribution lines, provide meters to consumers, etc.

How about plans to commence expansion of Egbin 2

We believe in Nigeria. From the beginning, we had articulated a vision to bring light to Nigeria. As part of that vision, we said from Day One that we will double the capacity of Egbin. But, how do you do that with all these challenges, including serious liquidity crisis, uneven playing field, policy summersault by government and mounting debts. The DISCOs would want to distribute electricity. But, they are limited by the tariffs and the differentials in the agreements they signed and the ones being implemented. They need all the enablers in place to perform optimally. We are determined to forge head believing that everything would come together soon.

Are you going to look from private capital to forge ahead

Obviously, that’s what we are doing.

So, where are you looking at

We have been engaging several partners in the quest for raising more capital. We are currently in discussions with some respected International organisations on various partnership models.

Where would that take you to

That would give us 3,120 MWs in four years’ time. But, we hope to attain a 5,000MW capacity in the next five years. Beyond Nigeria, we are making forays into other parts of Africa, where we plan to have strong footprints under the Sahara Group Electrifying Africa initiative. We have gone to Tanzania. We are making efforts to get into other nations we see as hubs. Recently, the Bureau for Public Enterprises said about 37% of privatized entities since its inception are not working. Nigerians say most of these entities may be in the power sector. Perhaps this is the best way to start.

What’s your view about the state of the sector today

At the moment, the power sector could do with more collaboration and synergy among all stakeholders to consolidate and enhance the gains from the privatization exercise.

How do you mean

The challenges in the sector are not only well known, but well documented. The system is not properly aligned to deliver service as desired. The sector is a value chain including all the players – gas suppliers, electricity generation, transmission and distribution companies. All stakeholders need to align properly to deliver electricity constantly to consumers. Today, a significant increase in gas supply has resulted in a ramp up in electricity supply from most of the power generation companies. Equally, there is significant growth in transmission capacity. Most the transmission projects previously uncompleted have now been completed. The wheeling capacity of transmission has improved proportionately to about 7,000 megawatts, MW of electricity. But, there’s a wide gap in what we are delivering. That’s where the challenge is. Electricity business is a global business. It’s nothing unique to Nigeria. The variables and enablers are known globally. There must be gas availability in the desired quantity and what can be piped from the location it is produced to the power plant. As long as one can do that optimally, there will be availability of electricity. The generation company must also have the capacity to take the gas and use in producing the power for the transmission company to be able to give the various distribution entities. But, it is evident from the state of the industry today that there are gaps. From the gas suppliers, a lot of money is invested in the development of gas fields, provision of infrastructure and supply facilities. They would need to recover their costs. The moment they cannot recover their investment, the appetite to continue to develop the gas fields would drop. To survive, they would begin to look for alternative markets where gas can be economically priced. From the generation perspective, the GENCOs import most of its machines and spare parts used in generating electricity. Again, don’t forget electricity is a regulated business in the country. There is a document called multi-year tariff order that puts into context different parameters for the tariffs charged by the GENCOs, Transco and DISCOs. The day the tariff is lower than the cost of production in the entire value chain, failure begins to set in. That is the position we have today in the Nigerian power sector. The gaps we are seeing is regulatory in nature, because the system is completely regulated, in terms of the standards, quality, pricing and operators activities. Pricing relates directly with availability of liquidity. If the commodity is appropriately priced, the production process would be oiled to continue to produce.

What do you think needs to be done to move to the next level

We need to dimension in the fullest essence possible what it would take to supply electricity – in terms of technical, legal, commercial, regulation, pricing, liquidity, infrastructure, spare parts and equipment, etc. When the market has been properly dimensioned, in terms of requirements for gas-fired, hydro and renewable plants, along with all the enablers in the true state they should be, all parties would then agree on each of their roles. Government should be committed to face the critical parameters involving monetary policies on interest rates on loans, exchange rate and inflation rate. These could be pegged at a certain levels to allow the power sector bring in the required infrastructure. But, we need to quickly dimension the issue of pricing for the sector to have stability in supply.

If you were to be government, what would you do to make the sector work

If government wants to industrialize Nigeria, it can say the cost of goods and services should not be high. A critical component of the analysis to achieve that agenda would be adequate electricity supply as a policy. I will say goods and services must be made to be competitive to allow export, or encourage industrial users of electricity to activate the country’s economy. With that, I would have aligned the country’s energy policy with industrial policy, by bringing down cost in order to unleash industrialization. Again, I would ensure that government helps to reduce the inefficiencies that make operators unable to provide cost-effective electricity. Government should not default in obligations.

If you were to adjust the regulatory environment, which area would you focus on

A regulator’s job is made easier under a climate of reasonable certainty. Where there is high degree of uncertainty, regulatory functions becomes almost impossible. Today, we have a seemingly better regulatory environment, despite challenges here and there. In the past we had significant policy summersault that did not allow for adequate planning. There shouldn’t be any disconnect between policy and regulation.

What about the issue of tariff structure for gas supply

There are three strategies here. Total energy driven market that allows costs to be fed in and priced, with the regulator’s role only to ensure that nobody makes excessive profit. But, free market is not practicable now. On the other hand, I will say: Let government provide these services. But, we know government alone cannot provide these services. This is where the public-private partnership comes in. Government can say the entire value chain of the energy sector is the only way Nigeria could become economically great. Then government could say: How do I help the players deliver electricity to consumers efficiently, effectively in a sustainable manner. The value chain starts with gas supply for the thermal plants. Without gas supply the entire value chain is useless. Government needs to sit down with everybody in the sector and dimension the requirements for the sector to succeed and accept the incremental stages the sector will go through and how to get there. After that, we can look at the financial and investment sides for the industry to have commercially viable price that would give the desired support and the expected result. Then, the realities of all the parties would be documented in a masterplan that would drive the entire energy sector value chain. Then, there must be that commitment to agreements. I always like to adopt an holistic and unified approach in looking at this issue. That is what is required to make the system work well. There must be regular gas to generation side of the value chain to deliver power optimally. Gas must not treated in isolation. Everything that would enable more electricity to be delivered to consumers must be resolved holistically. The more GENCOs are able to deliver power, the more money they make. This is why Egbin 2 expansion project is in the works to position the nation’s largest power plant for the growth we envision in the power sector in Nigeria and across the continent.

Privatization of the power sector was seen as the magic bullet that would change everything


Why did you say that

Because the Nigerian power sector is like the human body. When one has headache, it’s because of certain misalignment of one body organ against another, for which the headache is just a symptom. If one buys a pain reliever to treat the headache, one would be engaging in self-deceit. The proximate cause of the headache has not been dealt with. Providing half solution is worse, as is being done today. If one does not know the cause of the problem, chances are that one would be running around in circles, looking for scapegoats. Everybody in the power sector has been looking for who to blame for the problems. Nobody has taken time to know what the proximate cause of providing stable electricity in Nigeria is. The truth is simply that there is a serious misalignment in the system. This is where the problem is. The day there is an alignment of all the relevant players and elements in the power sector working together in synergy, electricity will become available on a regular basis.

But privatization seems not to have solved our problems

Yes, because of the misalignment I have talked about. Yet, in Egbin Power station where I am the Chairman, when it was privatized, it was generating about 400 MWs of electricity. Today, Egbin is generating 1,100 MW. In terms of contribution to the national grid, Egbin has increased its capacity significantly post-privatization. Without government putting in any money, the company has been able to get funding that has lifted the plant from what it was to what it is today. But, the mistake that was made by government after privatization was that the amount harvested from the exercise should have been reinvested in the system for the upgrade of the infrastructure. If government, with all the resources at its disposal, handled the system for over 53 years and could not provide all the infrastructure and meter all the customers, how would the same government expect the private sector to do all that in just five years of privatization, even with a growing population?

Related Stories

Fire Guts Supreme Court Complex in Abuja

By Bliss Okperan A news report filtering in indicates that a part of the Supreme Court complex in Abuja has been gutted by fire. The incident, according to what Business Post gathered, happened on Monday morning. It was said that offices of three justices were affected by the inferno, whose cause is yet unknown at the time of filing this report. Details later…


Independence: FG Declares Monday October 2 Public Holiday

By Adedapo Adesanya The federal government has declared Monday, October 2, 2023, a public holiday to celebrate Nigeria’s 63rd Independence Day, which falls on Sunday, October 1. The Minister of Interior, Mr Olubunmi Tunji-Ojo, made this known in a statement signed by the ministry’s Permanent Secretary, Mrs Oluwatoyin Akinlade, in Abuja on Thursday. Mr Olubunmi acknowledged the global socio-economic hardship, noting that Nigeria is not excluded. He, however, reasserted the government’s commitment to tackling the issues facing the country to reassure Nigerians. “It is today a known fact that difficult Socio-Economic and Security challenges are global, and Nigeria is not


Nigeria Unveils Initiative to Boost Youth Employment, FX Earnings

By Adedapo Adesanya An initiative to boost youth employment and shore up Nigeria’s foreign exchange (FX) earnings has been introduced by the Nigerian government. The scheme, the National Talent Export Programme (NATEP), was unveiled over the weekend at the Microsoft Office in New York, United States of America by the Minister of Industry, Trade and Investment, Mrs Doris Uzoka-Anite. She said the programme would position Nigeria as an export hub for talent outsourcing in Africa following the example of India, Bangladesh, Mexico and The Philippines. Mrs Uzoka-Anite noted that NATEP is a key national initiative that will serve as a

More Stories

US Stocks May Move Back Upside in Early Trading

By Investors Hub Major U.S. index futures are pointing to a higher opening on Thursday, with the Dow futures up by 83 points. The upward momentum on Wall Street comes following the weakness seen over the two previous sessions. After moving to the downside early in the session, stocks climbed off their worst levels of the day on Wednesday but remained mostly in negative territory. The Dow ended the day down by 138.19 points or 0.6 percent at 23,271.28. the Nasdaq dropped 31.66 points to 6,706.21 and the S&P 500 fell 14.25 points or 0.6 percent to 2,563.62. The weakness


FAAC Plans New Revenue Template for NNPC, Shares N715b

By Dipo Olowookere A new revenue reporting template is being prepared by the Federation Accounts Allocation Committee (FAAC) for the Nigerian National Petroleum Corporation (NNPC) and other members of the revenue sharing committee. Minister of Finance, Mrs Kemi Adeosun, at a news briefing on Thursday in Abuja, disclosed that the new template would address the key areas of disputes between Governors of the 36 states of the federation and the state-owned oil firm. According to her, the committee constituted to work on the new template should submit a draft before the next meeting for review. There had been disputes between


Shareholders Describe Segun Agbaje as Blessing to GTBank

By Dipo Olowookere The Managing Director/Chief Executive Officer of Guaranty Trust Bank (GTBank) Plc, Mr Segun Agbaje, has been described as a blessing to the financial institution, shareholders and stakeholders. This year, Mr Agbaje would have been in the position for 10 years and within the period, he has made GTBank stronger in the banking industry. Over the weekend, the bank held its Annual General Meeting (AGM) in Lagos and at the gathering, shareholders unanimously approved the payment of a total dividend of N3.00 per share for the financial year ended December 31, 2020. The lender had proposed a final


African Americans, Misinformation Crisis, Wisdom and Civil Rights

By Nneka Okumazie There is a hole that the lack of wisdom presents that makes anything possessed become of low worth. To believe that accusing others of things as something worthy of expression is confusing what progress should mean. What should be obvious is that those who were evil in slavery years ago were not wise, they may claim to be better than others, but they were not wise. They forgot what it might mean for the future of their place and their people and how long it might take to correct the mistake. The same lack of wisdom is


Naira Appreciates Amid Surge in Forex Demand

By Adedapo Adesanya Despite a significant increase in the demand for foreign currencies at the Investors and Exporters (I&E) segment of the foreign exchange (forex) market on Tuesday, September 21, the Naira appreciated against the United States Dollar. Business Post reports that the Nigerian Naira gained 40 kobo or 0.10 per cent against the greenback yesterday to trade at N413.28/$1 at the market window in contrast to N413.68/$1 it traded at the first trading session of the week. A turnover of $200.65 million was recorded at the session as against the $91.23 million achieved at the preceding day, indicating a


UNHCR Seeks $135m for Fleeing Boko Haram Victims

By Dipo Olowookere The United Nations refugee agency, United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR), has launched an appeal for $135 million to assist hundreds of thousands of people displaced by the worsening Boko Haram insurgency in the Lake Chad Basin region. The appeal, tagged 2019 Nigeria Regional Refugee Response Plan (RRRP), was launched in partnership with the UN Development Programme and other partners. With more 250,000 children, women and men already uprooted from northeast Nigeria, surging militant attacks targeting civilians and are forcing thousands more to run for their lives each day. Young girls, old women and aid workers


Value of Stocks on NSE Drops N55bn to N12.625trn

By Dipo Olowookere The total value of shares on the floor of the Nigerian Stock Exchange (NSE) as captured by the market capitalisation depreciated on Monday by N55 billion. The loss, about 0.44 per cent, was influenced by profit-taking activities of investors, who quickly rebalanced their portfolios after the gains recorded in the past sessions. This led to the reduction of the market capitalisation yesterday to N12.625 trillion from N12.680 trillion it closed last Friday when the bourse appreciated by 0.12 per cent. Business Post reports that the losses came from 17 stocks led by Mobil Oil as the share


Heritage Bank Woos Golfers at Ikoyi Club 38

By Dipo Olowookere A monthly mugs competition of the Ikoyi Club 38 in Lagos has received a huge boost with the sponsorship of the event by Heritage Bank Plc. The tournament is played by members only and at the end, gifts, in form of mugs, are given to winners. MD/CEO of Heritage Bank, Mr Ifie Sekibo, explained that the bank partnered the club because “we needed to pitch our tent where it matters, needed to be visible and to put our footprint in the sands of time.” Mr Sekibo, represented at the last event by the Regional Head, Lagos Island

Recent Stories

LCCI Seeks Upward Review of N30,000 Minimum Wage

By Adedapo Adesanya The Lagos Chamber of Commerce and Industry (LCCI) has described Nigeria’s minimum wage of N30,000 ($30) for 30 days as extremely poor and called for an urgent upward review of the wage structure. The President of LCCI, Mr Michael Olawale-Cole, during the chamber’s Independence Day message on Sunday, said an appraisal of the past 63 years showed that the Nigerian economy had performed sub-optimally with huge implications on citizens’ welfare and rising uncertainty. It noted that the economy was struggling with difficult conditions including high inflation, weak currency, declining reserves, falling household purchasing power, rising debt burden,


Kariko, Weissman Win Nobel Medicine Prize for COVID-19 Vaccines Research

By Adedapo Adesanya Scientists Katalin Kariko and Drew Weissman won the 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine for discoveries enabling the development of COVID-19 vaccines, the award-giving body said on Monday. The prize, among the most prestigious in the scientific world, is selected by the Nobel Assembly of Sweden’s Karolinska Institute Medical University and also comes with 11 million Swedish crowns (about $1 million). “The 2023 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine has been awarded to Katalin Karikó and Drew Weissman for their discoveries concerning nucleoside base modifications that enabled the development of effective mRNA vaccines against COVID-19,” the


Ecobank Alerts Customers on Rise in SIM Swap Fraud

By Modupe Gbadeyanka Customers of Ecobank Nigeria have been urged to remain on the alert as some scammers are taking advantage of SIM swaps to dupe their unsuspecting victims. The financial institution issued this alert in an email message to customers, urging them not to lose guard. The bank said phone users, who attached their mobile numbers to their bank accounts, to take extra caution when swapping their SIM cards, so as not to be victims of fraudsters. The lender explained to customers that SIM swap fraud occurs when scammers use your phone number to access your accounts. “Scammers impersonate


Oando-Eni Deal: Workers Threaten to Shutdown Operations

By Adedapo Adesanya  The Petroleum and Natural Gas Senior Staff Association of Nigeria (PENGASSAN) has vowed to down tools and shut down all oil field locations if demands following the acquisition of Nigerian Agip Oil Company (NAOC) are not met. Business Post had reported in September that Oando Plc had acquired a 100 per cent stake in the Nigerian subsidiary of Italian giant, Eni. However, the deal allegedly happened without management addressing the welfare and benefits of the workers and without due process. The development has led to several protests by members of PENGASSAN since the beginning of September 2023.


Exploring The Capabilities Of The ChatGPT Trading Bot In Today’s Market

Traders Union (TU) recently took an interest in ChatGPT, a chatbot by OpenAI. Think of ChatGPT as a super-smart robot friend who loves to chat about almost anything! It’s famous for giving detailed answers to loads of questions. But, like every friend, it might get things wrong sometimes. There’s a free version everyone can chat with, and a fancier version called ChatGPT Plus for those who want more. Some even call it the “ChatGPT trading bot” because of its extensive knowledge about trading. ChatGPT’s trading capabilities Without a doubt, ChatGPT has carved a niche for itself in the automated trading


Tinubu Increases Planned Monthly Allowance to N35,000

By Adedapo Adesanya President Bola Tinubu has increased the initially proposed monthly allowance for federal civil servants from N25,000 to N35,000. The money is still to be paid monthly for six months. The increment was announced in a statement by the Minister of Information, Mr Mohammed Idris. This development came less than 24 hours after Mr Tinubu on his first Independence Day broadcast on Sunday morning announced the monthly payment of N25,000 allowance to junior civil servants to cushion the effect of the impact of petrol subsidy removal. He said the allowance would be paid for six months. However, after


Boosting Website Performance: Tips for Speed and Efficiency

By Rahul Baitha In today’s digital age, where instant gratification is the norm, website performance plays a critical role in delivering a positive user experience. Visitors expect websites to load quickly and respond seamlessly to their interactions. If your website lags or stumbles, you risk losing valuable traffic and potential customers. As a web designer or business owner, optimizing your website’s performance should be a top priority. In this comprehensive guide, we’ll explore essential tips and techniques to boost your website’s speed and efficiency. Understanding Website Performance Before diving into optimization strategies, it’s essential to grasp the fundamentals of website


NDLEA Nabs Suspected Kingpin in UK Drug Export Bust

By Adedapo Adesanya The National Drug Law Enforcement Agency (NDLEA) has arrested a suspect wanted for attempts to ship illicit drug consignments to the United Kingdom. This was made known in a statement signed by the NDLEA spokesman, Mr Femi Babafemi, on Sunday. He further disclosed arrests made by NDLEA operatives through interdiction operations that led to the seizure of four tons of illicit substances in the past week. According to the agency, the suspect, Mr Obiorah Chigozie, had been on its wanted list since September 15. This, he said, was when a consignment of 1.500kg skunk concealed in flour


BUA Cement Slashes Ex-Factory Prices to N3,500

By Aduragbemi Omiyale The management of BUA Cement Plc has announced a reduction in the prices of its cement from its factory without the transportation costs to N3,500 per bag (50kg). The cement maker confirmed this development in a statement issued on Sunday, noting that it was part of efforts to make sure customers get the products at cheaper prices. In the statement, BUA Cement disclosed that the slash in cement prices is from Monday, October 2, 2023, urging its distributors not to fleet the end users. The firm said, “All pending, undelivered orders which had been paid for at


NITDA Opens Applications for Tech Accelerator Fellowship

By Adedapo Adesanya The federal government through the National Information Technology Development Agency (NITDA) has opened applications for a tech startup accelerator fellowship program to empower Nigerians with innovative ideas. The Minister of Communications, Innovation and Digital Economy, Mr Bosun Tijani, said the preparations for the training commenced in August with a meeting of stakeholders in tech to co-create innovative ways to achieve the target. He added that the meeting was the first in a series of ecosystem engagements to ensure that the government gets the best solutions from within. The new initiative from the NITDA is part of the