South Africa: ICC Move Betrays Victims

Image

south-africa

By Ebitonye Akpodigha

South Africa’s announced withdrawal from the International Criminal Court (ICC) treaty represents an enormous blow to its commitment to justice for atrocity crimes, Human Rights Watch said today. ICC members committed to accountability for the gravest crimes should reaffirm their support for the court at this time.

On October 21, 2016, South Africa’s foreign minister, Maite Nkoana-Mashabane, announced that South Africa had submitted a notice to United Nations Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon of its intent to withdraw as a party to the Rome Statute, the treaty that established and governs the ICC.

Notification is necessary to trigger the withdrawal, which comes into effect a year after such notice is given.

“South Africa’s withdrawal would be a huge reversal of its role as a leader promoting victims’ rights and the values in its post-apartheid constitution,” said Richard Dicker, International Justice director at Human Rights Watch. “It’s also unclear whether the South African government followed its own laws, not least because it did not consult parliament.”

South Africa is the only government that has given notice to withdraw its membership of the court since historic creation of the court in 1998.

The court’s mandate is to hold perpetrators of genocide, war crimes, and crimes against humanity to account when national courts are unable or unwilling to prosecute them for their crimes.

Prior to South Africa’s notification of withdrawal, Burundi’s Parliament passed a law for ICC withdrawal. The government of Burundi, however, has not submitted any notice to the UN secretary-general, which is needed to begin the withdrawal process.

Distinguished jurists and advocates in South Africa expressed dismay that their government submitted a notification of withdrawal without parliamentary authorization. Former South African Constitutional Court judge Richard Goldstone called the move unconstitutional. Goldstone was also the first chief prosecutor of the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia and the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda. The Democratic Alliance, one of South Africa’s main opposition parties, and the Southern Africa Litigation Centre, a prominent human rights organization, signalled they may challenge the move in South Africa’s courts.

Nkoana-Mashabane claimed that a reason for South Africa’s withdrawal is that the government cannot conduct peace negotiations with parties in armed conflict because of its obligations to the ICC. However, the ICC treaty does not bar any active role in peace negotiations.

“South Africa’s leading role in developing principles for an effective and independent court makes the Zuma government’s decision especially troubling,” said Dicker. “South Africa has made a profoundly negative decision for victims and the rule of law.”

The Southern Africa Development Community (SADC) developed 10 principles on the establishment of the ICC at a meeting convened by South Africa in Pretoria in September 1997. These principles were a major positive contribution to the court’s effective creation, and represented a strong commitment by South Africa and the rest of SADC for a permanent, global war crimes court.

South Africa’s withdrawal from the ICC has been met with an outcry from activists across Africa. In a statement issued on October 21, African groups and international organizations with a presence in Africa called the move “a devastating blow for victims of international crimes across Africa” and urged other African ICC members – including Ivory Coast, Nigeria, Senegal, and Tunisia – to publicly affirm their support for the court.

Senegal’s minister of justice, Sadiki Kaba, who is the president of the ICC’s 124-member Assembly of States Parties, has asked South Africa to reconsider its position and “to work together with other States in the fight against impunity, which often causes massive violations of human rights.” Kaba is to hold a news conference in Dakar on October 24 on the issue.

South Africa’s withdrawal takes places amidst a backlash against the ICC emanating from Sudan and Kenya, both of whose leaders have faced charges by the court. Attacks on the ICC focus on claims that the court is targeting Africa.

While all but one of the ICC’s investigations to date are in Africa, the majority have been initiated following a request of an African government.

However, the ICC works in a global landscape where the disparity of political, economic, and military power is stark. A number of the most powerful countries, including three permanent members of the UN Security Council – Russia, China, and the United States – and their allies have not joined the court and have thus been able to avoid ICC scrutiny. The permanent members of the security council have used their veto privilege to block referral to the ICC of situations desperately in need of justice in countries that are not ICC members, including Syria.

Since 2009, activists across Africa have joined with international groups to call for African governments to support and strengthen the ICC, instead of undermining it.

“African states played a foundational role in creating the ICC, which marked a significant shift towards ensuring that no one is above the law and everyone deserves justice,” said Dicker. “We need to strengthen the court’s delivery of justice and extend its reach to more countries. But the goal of justice, including redress and reparations for victims, is too important to throw away because of flaws in the global system.”

Share
Related Stories
Image
12-February-2024

LinkedIn Records 11.5 million Data Leaks in 2023

By Adedapo Adesanya Business and employment-focused social media platform, LinkedIn, recorded over 11 million data leaks in 2023, a new study has revealed from cybersecurity firm, Surfshark. In 2023, LinkedIn had almost 11.5 million emails leaked due to the scraping of publicly available information. Out of the leaked accounts, 1.6 million were American, 1.1 million were French, and 700,000 were British. Four Russian platforms, Chitai-gorod, Book24, Gloria Jeans, and SberSpasibo, experienced the 2nd through 5th biggest data breaches. These breaches exposed around 20 million Russian email accounts. According to the data, 300 million user account data were leaked globally in

Image
06-February-2024

International Food Prices Dip Further in January 2024—FAO

By Adedapo Adesanya Global food prices fell further in January 2024, mainly on lower wheat and maize prices, according to the latest data from the United Nations’ Food and Agriculture Organisation (FAO). The FAO Food Price Index (FFPI), which is used to gauge aggregate pricing, stood at 118.0 points in January 2024, down 1.2 points (1.0 per cent) from its revised December level. Decreases in the price indices for cereals and meat more than offset an increase in the sugar price index, while those for dairy and vegetable oils only registered slight adjustments. The index stood 13.7 points (10.4 per

Image
29-December-2023

Turkey Joins Africa Finance Corporation With New Equity Investment

By Adedapo Adesanya Turkey has joined the Africa Finance Corporation (AFC) as its first non-African sovereign shareholder following an equity investment from Turk Eximbank. AFC, an infrastructure solutions provider, announced that the equity subscription from Turkey’s official export credit agency will advance its mission to be the bridge between Africa and global stakeholders wishing to play a key role in the continent’s development and prosperity. According to a statement on Friday, Turk Eximbank’s investment in AFC is its first in an African entity and aligns with Turkey’s strategic vision of fostering resilient and sustainable growth in Africa, as outlined in

Image
19-February-2024

Practical Ideas of Russian-African Club for Strengthening Russia-Africa Relations

By Gouend Louis On February 8, the Russian-African Club of MSU named after M.V. Lomonosov held an International Conference: “Development of cultural and humanitarian cooperation between Russia and African countries.” The event took place at the Faculty of Global Processes of Moscow State University. The conference was held as part of the implementation of the decisions of the Second Summit and the Russia-Africa Economic and Humanitarian Forum, which was held on July 27-28, 2023. in St. Petersburg. The event was supported by the Secretariat of the Russia-Africa Partnership Forum of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Russian Federation. The

More Stories
Image
17-December-2023

SERAP Sues INEC Over Failure to Persecute Off-Cycle Elections Offenders

By Adedapo Adesanya The Socio-Economic Rights and Accountability Project (SERAP) has filed a lawsuit against the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) after the body ignored its earlier call to prosecute electoral offenders at the three off-cycle state elections held on November 11, 2023. This was disclosed in a statement on Sunday by SERAP’s deputy director, Mr Kolawole Oluwadare, saying the group’s suit followed the alleged failure of the electoral body to “arrest and prosecute suspected perpetrators of grave electoral offences in the recently concluded off-cycle governorship elections in Kogi, Imo and Bayelsa states.” In the suit number FHC/ABJ/CS/1694/2023 filed last

Image
10-July-2019

NSE Fines Conoil N.4m, May Delist Omatek

By Dipo Olowookere The Nigerian Stock Exchange (NSE) has asked Conoil Plc, an energy company trading its shares on the local bourse, to pay a fine of N400,000. Business Post gathered this money is to be paid by the firm, which has billionaire businessman, Mr Mike Adenuga, as its chairman, for filing its financial statements late. Recall that few days ago, the NSE suspended trading in the shares of the company and 10 others for failing to submit their financial statements for the year ended December 31, 2018 and the first quarter of 2019. “Dealing members are hereby notified that

Image
11-February-2021

LASUTH to Investigate Allegation of Fake COVID-19 Certificate

By Dipo Olowookere The management of Lagos State University Teaching Hospital (LASUTH) has said it would investigate an allegation that one of its personnel was involved in the issuance of fake COVID-19 certificate to a traveller. A new investigative platform founded by Mr ‘Fisayo Soyombo, Foundation for Investigative Journalism, had published a report written by one Adeola Oladipupo, alleging that an official of LASUTH connived with those at the Biosafety Laboratory, Yaba to give out fake COVID results to travellers. But LASUTH distanced itself from the allegation, stressing that being a reputable public health organisation, it does not harbour such

Image
18-November-2021

Seplat Energy Chairman ABC Orjiako Steps Down After 12 Years

By Dipo Olowookere The Chairman of Seplat Energy Plc, Mr A.B.C Orjiako, will be stepping down from the position in May 2020, a statement from the company has disclosed. The businessman has been in the eye of the storm lately but it was not stated in the notice if his decision to step down was connected to reports in the media. It was revealed that Mr Orjiako is exiting the board of the company at the next annual general meeting (AGM) of the organisation slated for next year when he will be succeeded by an independent chairperson in line with

Image
12-January-2021

KEDCO Groans as Electricity Consumers Owe N17.6bn

By Adedapo Adesanya The management of Kano Electricity Distribution Company (KEDCO) said it was yet to collect over N17.6 billion owed by energy consumers in its coverage areas. KEDCO supplies power to residents of Kano, Katsina and Jigawa and the N17.6 billion is the outstanding electricity bills for the whole of 2020. The Head of Corporate Communications at KEDCO, Mr Ibrahim Sani Shawai, in a statement disclosed that “the uncollected bills was as a result of zero payment, under-payment, half payment and part payments from our numerous customers and this often leaves huge outstanding which has accumulated to the above

Image
11-April-2018

Geopolitical Concerns Pile Pressure on US Markets

By Investors Hub The major U.S. index futures are pointing to a lower opening on Wednesday following the strong upward move seen in the previous session. Traders may cash in on yesterday?s gains amid geopolitical concerns after President Donald Trump warned Russia ?get ready? for missiles being launched at Syria. Stocks moved sharply higher during trading on Tuesday, adding to the modest gains posted in the previous session. The major averages ended the day firmly in positive territory. The Dow jumped 428.90 points or 1.8 percent to 24,408.00, the Nasdaq soared 143.96 points or 2.1 percent to 7,094.30 and the

Image
26-October-2019

Prof Fabanwo Lists Major Causes of Maternal Mortality

**Says Women Deserve Better Reproductive Experience Chief Medical Director (CMD) of the Lagos State University Teaching Hospital (LASUTH), Prof. Adetokunbo O. Fabamwo, has reiterated that women deserve better reproductive experience. The medical practitioner made this disclosure while delivering a lecture at the National Women’s Conference of Committee of Wife of Lagos State Officials (COWLSO) with the theme Unlearn, Learn and Relearn: 21st Century Women’s THEMES Perspectives and Approach on Wednesday, October 23, 2019. The Professor of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, while presenting his lecture titled Maternal and Neonatal Mortality at the event in its 19th edition, stated that pregnancy bleeding, hypertensive

Image
02-July-2019

Samsung Excites Nigerian Customers with Latest 4K, 8K QLED TVs

South Korean multinational conglomerate, Samsung Electronics, has announced the availability of its 2019 QLED TV line at selected stores in Nigeria. The product, which comes in 4K and 8K, features more screen size options, stunning picture quality enhancements, dazzling colours from every angle, exciting new design elements and intuitive smart TV upgrades. Samsung’s QLED line-up offers 4K and 8K models in a range of sizes to suit the needs of every home and every lifestyle including: QLED 8K Q900: 98″, 82″, 75″, 65″ and QLED 4K in Q80: 75″, 65″, 55″ and Q60: 82″, 65″, 55″. The 2019 QLED TV

Ad
Ad
Recent Stories
Image
23-February-2024

How MultiChoice Empowers Nigerian Youth Through Creative Investment

As global populations age, Africa remains a bastion of youthful promise, with around 70% of the continent’s population below the age of 30. This youthful demographic can be an asset – but only if it is developed, by empowering young people through training, and by giving them a stake in the growth of their countries’ economies. Helping to develop young people’s abilities and expanding the pool of skills is also in the interests of industry and big business. Over the years, the Federal government of Nigeria embarked on youth empowerment initiatives to harness the skills and energy of Nigerian youths

Image
23-February-2024

Eva Adelaja Girls’ At 60: Old Students Donate to Orphanage, Thrill Students

By Adedapo Adesanya It has been an eventful celebration at the ongoing 6oth Anniversary of Eva Adelaja Girls’ Secondary Grammar School, Bariga, Lagos. The event was planned to celebrate the institution established by the late educator, Mrs Evangeline Adebayo Adelaja, in 1964. Particular resplendent in this celebration are the alumni of the school, the Eva Adelaja Girls’ Secondary Grammar School Old Girls’ Association, which have been on the ground to ensure that the planned activities go smoothly. The event, which kicked off with the Praise Day and Community Hymn Singing held at Chapel of Christ the Light in Alausa, Ikeja,

Image
23-February-2024

FAAC Disburses N1.2trn to FG, States, Councils for February Allocation

By Aduragbemi Omiyale About N1.2 trillion, precisely N1.149 trillion, has been disbursed to the federal, state and local councils as their allocation for February 2024. The money was part of the revenue generated by the nation in January 2024. A total of N2.068 trillion was generated last month by Nigeria, but N1.149 trillion was shared, comprising distributable statutory revenue of N463.079 billion, Value Added Tax (VAT) of N391.787 billion, Electronic Money Transfer Levy (EMTL) of N15.922 billion, and Exchange Difference revenue of N279.028 billion. A communiqué issued after the end of the Federation Account Allocation Committee (FAAC) meeting held yesterday

Image
23-February-2024

Unlisted Securities Rise 0.33% After Recording Two Price Gainers

By Adedapo Adesanya The NASD Over-the-Counter (OTC) Securities Exchange recorded a 0.33 per cent appreciation on Thursday, February 22. This increased the wealth of investors by N5.16 billion during the session, with the market capitalisation growing to N1.576 trillion from the previous day’s N1.571 trillion. Following the same trend was the NASD Unlisted Security Index (NSI), which went up by 3.8 points to wrap the session at 1,162.77 points compared with 1,158.97 points recorded at the previous session. There were two gainers against one loser at the session on Thursday led by bellwethers – Aradel Holdings Plc and FrieslandCampina Wamco

Image
23-February-2024

Naira Falls at NAFEX, Parallel Market as Govt Battles Speculators

By Adedapo Adesanya Despite the unconventional approaches to ease the free fall of the Naira, its value weakened against the United States Dollar in the Nigerian Autonomous Foreign Exchange Market (NAFEM) on Thursday, February 22 by 1.9 per cent or N28.73 to close at N1,571.31/$1 compared with the N1,542.58/$1 it was transacted in the midweek session. The domestic currency suffered the loss despite the supply of foreign exchange (FX) improving by 11.7 per cent or $20.11 million to $192.25 million from Wednesday’s $172.14 million. However, the local currency appreciated against the Pound Sterling in the official market yesterday by N142.83

Image
23-February-2024

Oil Prices Up as Houthis Intensify Attacks in Trading Sea Routes

By Adedapo Adesanya  Oil prices went up on Thursday as Iran-aligned Houthis stepped up attacks in the Red Sea near Yemen while the market faced a large build in crude inventories in the world’s largest producer, the United States. During the session, Brent crude futures increased by 66 cents to $83.69 per barrel and the US West Texas Intermediate (WTI) crude futures surged by 76 cents to $78.67 a barrel. Worries came as the Houthis said they would escalate their attacks on ships in the Red Sea and other waters, adding they have introduced “submarine weapons” to reach their goals.

Image
23-February-2024

Customs Street Cracks by 0.12% as Traders Sell Off Wema Bank, Others

By Dipo Olowookere The bulls lost control of the Nigerian Exchange (NGX) Limited to the bears on Thursday amid sustained weak investor sentiment. Customs Street ended in the red zone by 0.12 per cent after it recorded 20 price advancers and 28 price laggards, implying a negative market breadth index. DAAR Communications was on top of the losers’ table yesterday after it let go of 10.00 per cent of its previous day’s closing price to trade at 72 Kobo. Wema Bank shed 9.93 per cent to sell at N7.80, PZ Cussons went down by 9.89 per cent to N24.60, Academy

Image
22-February-2024

FG to Resume Direct Cash Transfers to Poor Nigerians as Hunger Spreads

By Adedapo Adesanya Amid current realities, the federal government intends to restart direct cash transfers to the poorest and most vulnerable Nigerians, after a scandal led to the suspension of the programme last month. The Minister of Finance and Coordinating Minister for the Economy, Mr Wale Edun, revealed this during the Ministry’s retreat held in Uyo, Akwa-Ibom State. He said approximately three million people are recipients of the scheme but due to the escalating cost of living, the government anticipates that an additional 12 million households could qualify for these direct payments. The Finance Minister said, “The presidential panel on

Image
22-February-2024

Lagos Plans Daily Free Meal for Residents, Markets for Cheap Food Items

By Modupe Gbadeyanka About 1,500 residents of Lagos State will have access to one free meal per day to cushion the effect of the economic hardship in the country, Governor Babajide Sanwo-Olu has declared. Mr Sanwo-Olu, while answering questions from journalists during a media chat on Thursday, said his administration would establish at least 42 Sunday Markets across the metropolis for cheap food items, though the commencement of this initiative is yet to be revealed. There has been a pocket of demonstrations across the country over the rising hunger in Nigeria as a result of high inflation and the devaluation

Image
22-February-2024

WINBAFRICA Plans Big for 10th Anniversary

By Modupe Gbadeyanka All is now set for the 10th anniversary of WINBAFRICA themed Bridging the Gap: Celebrating a Decade of Nation-building. The organisation is gathering stakeholders together on Monday, February 26, 2024, for the event at the Alliance Francaise in Ikoyi, Lagos. The group was formed in 2014 and has since then promoted girl-child education and empowered women and young girls in critical thinking and leadership skills in secondary schools across Africa. As part of activities lined up for this year’s celebration, WINBAFRICA organised an annual school debate competition and scholarship programme for 20 young girls across the continent.